1495CHAPTER 197 Parvovirus Infections
amenable to investigational treatment with TPOXX or brincidofovir.
As mentioned above, vaccinia immune globulin is licensed for the
treatment of vaccinia infections.
■ FURTHER READING
Beer EM, Rao VB: A systematic review of the epidemiology of human
monkeypox outbreaks and implications for outbreak strategy. PLoS
Negl Trop Dis 13:e0007791, 2019.
Meza-Romero R et al: Molluscum contagiosum: An update and
review of new perspectives in etiology, diagnosis, and treatment. Clin
Cosmet Investig Dermatol 12:373, 2019.
Parvoviruses, members of the family Parvoviridae, are small (diameter,
~22 nm), nonenveloped, icosahedral viruses with a linear single-strand
DNA genome of ~5000 nucleotides. These viruses are dependent
on either rapidly dividing host cells or helper viruses for replication. At least five groups of parvoviruses infect humans: parvovirus
B19 (B19V), dependoparvoviruses (adeno-associated viruses; AAVs),
human tetraparvoviruses (PARV4 and PARV5), human bocaparvoviruses (HBoVs), and human protoparvoviruses (bufavirus, tusavirus,
and cutavirus). Human dependoparvoviruses are nonpathogenic and
will not be considered further in this chapter.
197 Parvovirus Infections
Kevin E. Brown
15
13
11
9
7
5
3
1
14
4
1.0
0.2
0
100
50
10
0
2 6 10 20
Days
Inoculation or infection
Normals
B19 Virus B19 Antibodies
Hemoglobin
(g%)
Clinical
manifestations
IgM
IgG
Reticulocytes
(g%)
10
Fever,
chills,
headache,
myalgia
Rash,
arthralgia
A 15
13
11
9
7
5
3
1
14
4
10
8
0
100
50
10
0
2 6 10 20
Days
Infection
TAC
B19 Virus B19 Antibodies
Hemoglobin
(g%)
Clinical
manifestations
IgM
IgG
Reticulocytes
(g%)
10
Symptoms
of anemia
B 15
13
11
9
7
5
3
1
14
4
10
8
0
100
50
10
0
2 6 10 20
Days
Infection
PRCA
B19 Virus B19 Antibodies
Hemoglobin
(g%)
Clinical
manifestations
IgM and IgG Reticulocytes
(g%)
10
Symptoms
of anemia
C
FIGURE 197-1 Schematic of the time course of parvovirus B19 infection in (A) normals (erythema infectiosum), (B) transient aplastic crisis (TAC), and (C) chronic anemia/
pure red cell aplasia (PRCA). (From NS Young, KE Brown: Parvovirus B19. N Engl J Med 350:586, 2004. Copyright © 2004 Massachusetts Medical Society. Reprinted with
permission from Massachusetts Medical Society.)
PARVOVIRUS B19
■ DEFINITION
B19V is the type member of the genus Erythroparvovirus. On the basis
of viral sequence, B19V is divided into three genotypes (designated 1,
2, and 3), but only a single B19V antigenic type has been described.
Genotype 1 is predominant in most parts of the world; genotype 2 is
rarely associated with active infection; and genotype 3 appears to predominate in parts of western Africa.
■ EPIDEMIOLOGY
B19V exclusively infects humans, and infection is endemic in virtually
all parts of the world. Transmission occurs predominantly via the
respiratory route and is followed by the onset of rash and arthralgia. By
the age of 15 years, ~50% of children have detectable IgG antibody to
B19V; this figure rises to >90% among the elderly. In pregnant women,
the estimated annual seroconversion rate is ~1%. Within households,
secondary infection rates approach 50%.
Detection of high-titer B19V in blood is not unusual (see “Pathogenesis,” below). Transmission can occur as a result of transfusion,
most commonly of pooled components. To reduce the risk of transmission, plasma pools are screened by nucleic acid amplification technology, and high-titer pools are discarded. B19V is resistant to both heat
and solvent-detergent inactivation.
■ PATHOGENESIS
B19V replicates primarily in erythroid progenitors. This specificity
is due in part to the limited tissue distribution of the primary B19V
receptor, blood group P antigen (globoside). Infection leads to hightiter viremia, with >1012 virus particles (or IU)/mL detectable in the
blood at the apex (Fig. 197-1), and virus-induced cytotoxicity results
1496 PART 5 Infectious Diseases
in cessation of red cell production. In immunocompetent individuals, viremia and arrest of erythropoiesis are transient and resolve as
the IgM and IgG antibody response is mounted. In individuals with
normal erythropoiesis, there is only a minimal drop in hemoglobin
levels; however, in those with increased erythropoiesis (especially with
hemolytic anemia), this cessation of red cell production can induce a
transient crisis with severe anemia (Fig. 197-1). Similarly, if an individual (or, after maternal infection, a fetus) does not mount a neutralizing
antibody response and halt the lytic infection, erythroid production is
compromised and chronic anemia develops (Fig. 197-1).
The immune-mediated phase of illness, which begins 2–3 weeks
after infection as the IgM response peaks, manifests as the rash of fifth
disease together with arthralgia and/or frank arthritis. Low-level B19V
DNA can be detected by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in blood and
tissues for months to years after acute infection. The B19V receptor is
found in a variety of other cells and tissues, including megakaryocytes,
endothelial cells, placenta, myocardium, and liver. Infection of these
tissues by B19V may be responsible for some of the more unusual
presentations of the infection. Rare individuals who lack P antigen are
naturally resistant to B19V infection.
■ CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
Erythema Infectiosum Most B19V infections are asymptomatic
or are associated with only a mild nonspecific illness. The main manifestation of symptomatic B19V infection is erythema infectiosum,
also known as fifth disease or slapped-cheek disease (Figs. 197-2 and
A1-1A). Infection begins with a minor febrile prodrome ~7–10 days
after exposure, and the classic facial rash develops several days later; after
2–3 days, the erythematous macular rash may spread to the extremities
in a lacy reticular pattern. However, its intensity and distribution vary,
and B19V-induced rash is difficult to distinguish from other viral exanthems. Adults typically do not exhibit the “slapped-cheek” phenomenon
but present with arthralgia, with or without the macular rash.
Polyarthropathy Syndrome Although uncommon among children, arthropathy occurs in ~50% of adults and is more common
among women than among men. The distribution of the affected
joints is often symmetrical, with arthralgia affecting the small joints
FIGURE 197-2 Young child with erythema infectiosum, or fifth disease, showing
typical “slapped-cheek” appearance.
of the hands and occasionally the ankles, knees, and wrists. Resolution usually occurs within a few weeks, but recurring symptoms can
continue for months. The illness may mimic rheumatoid arthritis, and
rheumatoid factor can often be detected in serum. B19V infection may
trigger rheumatoid disease in some patients and has been associated
with juvenile idiopathic arthritis.
Transient Aplastic Crisis Asymptomatic transient reticulocytopenia occurs in most individuals with B19V infection. However,
in patients who depend on continual rapid production of red cells,
infection can cause transient aplastic crisis (TAC). Affected individuals include those with hemolytic disorders, hemoglobinopathies, red
cell enzymopathies, and autoimmune hemolytic anemias. Patients
present with symptoms of severe anemia (sometimes life-threatening)
and a low reticulocyte count, and bone marrow examination reveals
an absence of erythroid precursors and characteristic giant pronormoblasts. As its name indicates, the illness is transient, and anemia
resolves with the cessation of cytopathic infection in the erythroid
progenitors.
Pure Red Cell Aplasia/Chronic Anemia Chronic B19V infection has been reported in a wide range of immunosuppressed patients,
including those with congenital immunodeficiency, AIDS (Chap. 202),
lymphoproliferative disorders (especially acute lymphocytic leukemia),
and transplantation (Chap. 143). Patients have persistent anemia with
reticulocytopenia, absent or low levels of B19V IgG, high titers of B19V
DNA in serum, and—in many cases—scattered giant pronormoblasts
in bone marrow. Rarely, nonerythroid hematologic lineages also are
affected. Transient neutropenia, lymphopenia, and thrombocytopenia
(including idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura) have been observed.
B19V occasionally causes a hemophagocytic syndrome.
Studies in Papua New Guinea, Gabon, and Ghana, where malaria is
endemic, suggest that co-infection with Plasmodium and B19V plays
a major role in the development of severe anemia in young children.
Case reports from other countries are rare, but further studies are
required to determine whether B19V infection contributes to severe
anemia in other malarial regions.
Hydrops Fetalis B19V infection during pregnancy can lead to
hydrops fetalis and/or fetal loss. The risk of transplacental fetal infection is ~30%, and the risk of fetal loss (predominantly early in the
second trimester) is ~9%. The risk of congenital infection is <1%.
Although B19V does not appear to be teratogenic, anecdotal cases of
eye damage and central nervous system (CNS) abnormalities have been
reported. Cases of congenital anemia have also been described. B19V
probably causes 10–20% of all cases of nonimmune hydrops.
Unusual Manifestations B19V infection may rarely cause hepatitis, vasculitis, myocarditis, glomerulosclerosis, or meningitis. A variety
of other cardiac manifestations, CNS diseases, and autoimmune infections have also been reported. However, B19V DNA can be detected
by PCR for years in many tissues; this finding is of no known clinical
significance, but its interpretation may cause confusion regarding
B19V disease association.
■ DIAGNOSIS
Diagnosis of B19V infection in immunocompetent individuals is generally based on detection of B19V IgM antibodies (Table 197-1). IgM can
be detected at the time of rash in erythema infectiosum and by the third
day of TAC in patients with hematologic disorders; these antibodies
remain detectable for ~3 months. B19V IgG is detectable by the seventh
day of illness and persists throughout life. Quantitative detection of
B19V DNA should be used for the diagnosis of early TAC or chronic
anemia. Although B19V levels fall rapidly with the development of the
immune response, DNA can be detectable by PCR for months or even
years after infection, even in healthy individuals; therefore, quantitative
PCR should be used. In acute infection at the height of viremia, >1012
B19V DNA IU/mL of serum can be detected; however, titers fall rapidly
within 2 days. Patients with aplastic crisis or B19V-induced chronic
anemia generally have >105
B19V DNA IU/mL.
1497CHAPTER 197 Parvovirus Infections
TABLE 197-1 Diseases Associated with Human Parvovirus B19 Infection and Methods of Diagnosis
DISEASE HOSTS IgM IgG PCR QUANTITATIVE PCR
Fifth disease Healthy children Positive Positive Positive >104
IU/mL
Polyarthropathy syndrome Healthy adults (more often
women)
Positive within 3 months
of onset
Positive Positive >104
IU/mL
Transient aplastic crisis Patients with increased
erythropoiesis
Negative/positive Negative/positive Positive Often >1012 IU/mL, but rapidly
decreases
Persistent anemia/pure
red cell aplasia
Immunodeficient or
immunocompetent patients
Negative/weakly positive Negative/weakly
positive
Positive Often >1012 IU/mL, but should be
>106
in the absence of treatment
Hydrops fetalis/congenital
anemia
Fetuses (<20 weeks) Negative/positive Positive Positive amniotic
fluid or tissue
n/a
Abbreviations: IU, international units (1 IU equals ~1 genome); n/a, not applicable; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.
TREATMENT
Parvovirus B19 Infection
No antiviral drug effective against B19V is available, and treatment
of B19V infection often targets symptoms only. TAC precipitated by
B19V infection frequently necessitates symptom-based treatment
with blood transfusions. In patients receiving chemotherapy, temporary cessation of treatment may result in an immune response
and resolution. If this approach is unsuccessful or not applicable,
commercial immune globulin (IVIg; Gammagard, Sandoglobulin)
from healthy blood donors can cure or ameliorate persistent B19V
infection in immunosuppressed patients. Generally, the dose used
is 400 mg/kg daily for 5–10 days. Like patients with TAC, immunosuppressed patients with persistent B19V infection should be
considered infectious. Administration of IVIg is not beneficial for
erythema infectiosum or B19V-associated polyarthropathy. Intrauterine blood transfusion can prevent fetal loss in some cases of
fetal hydrops.
■ PREVENTION
No vaccine has been approved for the prevention of B19V infection,
although vaccines based on B19V virus-like particles expressed in
insect cells are known to be highly immunogenic. Phase 1 trials of a
putative vaccine were discontinued because of adverse side effects.
HUMAN TETRAPARVOVIRUSES (PARV4/5)
■ DEFINITION
The PARV4 viral sequence was initially detected in a patient with an
acute viral syndrome. Similar sequences, including the related PARV5
sequence, have been detected in pooled plasma collections. The DNA
sequence of PARV4/5 is distinctly different from that of all other parvoviruses, and this virus is now classified as a member of the newly
described genus Tetraparvovirus.
■ EPIDEMIOLOGY
PARV4 DNA is commonly found in plasma pools but at lower concentrations than the levels of B19V DNA found before in plasma pools
prior to screening. The higher levels of PARV4 DNA and IgG antibody
in tissues (bone marrow and lymphoid tissue) and sera from IV drug
users than in the corresponding specimens from control patients suggest that the virus is transmitted predominantly by parenteral means in
the United States and Europe. Evidence for nonparenteral transmission
in other parts of the world is limited.
■ CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
To date, PARV4/5 infection has been associated only with mild clinical
disease (rash and/or transient aminotransferase elevation).
HUMAN BOCAPARVOVIRUSES
■ DEFINITION
Animal bocaparvoviruses are associated with mild respiratory symptoms and enteritis in young animals. Human bocavirus 1 (HBoV1)
was originally identified in the respiratory tract of young children
with lower respiratory tract infections. More recently, HBoV1 and the
related viruses HBoV2, HBoV3, and HBoV4 have all been identified
in human fecal samples.
■ EPIDEMIOLOGY
Seroepidemiologic studies with HBoV virus-like particles suggest that
HBoV infection is common. Worldwide, most individuals are infected
before the age of 5 years.
■ CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
HBoV1 DNA is found in respiratory secretions from 2–20% of children with acute respiratory infection, often in the presence of other
pathogens; in these circumstances, the role of HBoV1 in disease
pathogenesis is unknown. Clinical disease due to HBoV1 is associated with evidence of primary infection (IgG seroconversion or the
presence of IgM), HBoV1 DNA in serum, or high-titer HBoV1 DNA
(>104
genome copies/mL) in respiratory secretions. Symptoms are not
dissimilar from those of other viral respiratory infections, and cough
and wheezing are commonly reported. There is no specific treatment
for HBoV infection. The role of HBoVs in childhood gastroenteritis
remains to be established.
HUMAN PROTOPARVOVIRUSES
■ DEFINITION
Bufavirus, tusavirus, and cutavirus were all identified in clinical samples by a metagenomics approach used for identifying new pathogens.
These viruses are classified as members of the Protoparvovirus group
along with the original prototype member of the Parvoviridae, minute
virus of mice.
■ EPIDEMIOLOGY
Little is known about the epidemiology of these viruses. Antibodies
against bufavirus were very low in Finland and the United States (<4%)
but >50% in countries like Iraq, Iran, and Kenya. In contrast, antibodies against cutavirus were only found in <6% of all populations and
tusavirus antibodies in none. To date, tusavirus has been identified in
only a single patient with diarrhea in Tunisia, and it is not clear if it is
a human pathogen.
■ CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
Although bufavirus DNA is found in 0.2–4% of stools from children
and adults with diarrhea in many countries, often it is detected in
conjunction with other viruses. The role of bufavirus in childhood
gastroenteritis remains to be confirmed. Similarly, although cutavirus has been found in biopsies of individuals with cutaneous T-cell
lymphoma and melanoma, it has also been found in skin swabs from
healthy individuals.
■ FURTHER READING
Crabol Y et al: Intravenous immunoglobulin therapy for pure red
cell aplasia related to human parvovirus B19 infection: A retrospective study of 10 patients and review of the literature. Clin Infect Dis
56:968, 2013.
1498 PART 5 Infectious Diseases
Guido M et al: Human bocavirus: Current knowledge and future challenges. World J Gastroenterol 22:8684, 2016.
Maple PA et al: Identification of past and recent parvovirus B19
infection in immunocompetent individuals by quantitative PCR and
enzyme immunoassays: A dual-laboratory study. J Clin Microbiol
52:947, 2014.
Matthews PC et al: Human parvovirus 4 ‘PARV4’ remains elusive
despite a decade of study F1000 Res 6:82, 2017.
Söderlund-Venermo M: Emerging human parvoviruses: The rocky
road to fame. Ann Rev Virol 6:71, 2019.
Söderlund-Venermo M et al: Human parvoviruses, in Clinical
Virology, 4th ed. DD Richman et al (eds). Washington, DC, ASM
Press, 2016, pp 679–700.
Su C-C et al: Effects of antibodies against human parvovirus B19 on
angiogenic signaling. Mol Med Rep 21:1320, 2020.
Interest in human papillomavirus (HPV) infection began in earnest
in the 1980s after Harold zur Hausen postulated that infection with
these viruses was associated with cervical cancer. It is now recognized
that HPV infection of the human genital tract is extremely common
and causes clinical conditions ranging from asymptomatic infection to
genital warts (condylomata acuminata); dysplastic lesions and invasive
cancers of the anus, penis, vulva, vagina, and cervix; and a subset of
oropharyngeal cancers. This chapter describes the epidemiology of
HPV as a virus and a pathogen, the natural history of HPV infections
and associated cancers, strategies to prevent infection and HPVassociated disease, and treatment modalities for some conditions
caused by HPV.
■ PATHOGENESIS
Overview HPV is an icosahedral, nonenveloped, 8000-
base-pair, double-stranded DNA virus with a diameter of 55 nm.
Like the genomes of other papillomaviruses, HPV’s genome consists of an early (E) gene region, a late (L) gene region, and a noncoding
region, which contains regulatory elements. The E1, E2, E5, E6, and E7
proteins are expressed early in the growth cycle and are necessary for
viral replication and cellular transformation. The E6 and E7 proteins
are responsible for malignant transformation, targeting the human cellcycle regulatory molecules p53 and Rb (retinoblastoma protein) for
degradation, respectively. Translation of the L1 and L2 transcripts and
splicing of an E1^E4 transcript occur later. The L1 gene encodes the
54-kDa major capsid protein that makes up the majority of the virus
shell; the 77-kDa L2 minor protein contributes a smaller percentage of
the capsid mass.
More than 125 HPV types have been identified and are numerically
designated on the basis of a unique L1 gene sequence. Approximately
40 HPV types are regularly identified in the anogenital tract; these
types are subdivided into high-risk and low-risk categories depending
on the associated risk of cervical cancer. For example, HPV types 6 and
11 cause genital warts and ~10% of low-grade cervical lesions and are
thus designated low risk. HPV types 16 and 18 cause dysplastic lesions
and a high percentage of invasive cancers of the cervix and are therefore considered high risk.
HPV targets basal keratinocytes after microtrauma allows exposure
of these cells to the virus. The HPV replication cycle is completed as
keratinocytes undergo differentiation. Virions are assembled in the
198 Human Papillomavirus
Infections
Darron R. Brown, Aaron C. Ermel
nuclei of differentiated keratinocytes and can be detected by electron
microscopy. Infection is transmitted by contact with virus contained in
these desquamated keratinocytes (or with free virus) from an infected
individual.
The Immune Response to HPV Infection Unlike many viral
infections, HPV infection has no viremic phase. This lack of viremia
may account for the incomplete antibody response to HPV infection.
Natural HPV infection of the genital tract gives rise to a serum antibody response in 60–70% of individuals. Significant, although incomplete, protection against type-specific reinfection is associated with
the presence of neutralizing antibodies. Serum antibodies likely reach
the cervical epithelium and secretions by transudation and exudation.
Therefore, protection against infection relates to the amount of neutralizing antibody at the site of infection and lasts as long as sufficient
levels of neutralizing antibodies are present.
A cell-mediated immune response plays an important role in
controlling progression of HPV infection. Histologic examination
of lesions in individuals who experience regression of genital warts
demonstrates infiltration by T cells and macrophages. CD4+ T-cell
regulation is particularly important in controlling HPV infections,
as evidenced by the higher rates of infection and disease in immunosuppressed individuals, particularly those who are infected with HIV.
Specific T-cell responses may be measured against HPV proteins,
the most important of which appear to be the E2 and E6 proteins. In
women with HPV type 16 cervical infection, a strong T-cell response
to type 16–derived E2 protein is associated with a lack of progression
of cervical disease. However, measurable changes occur in the innate
and adaptive immune systems of patients with HPV-associated cancers. There is suppression of the antigen-presentation process as well
as suppression of antitumor activity. The end result is a reduction of
HPV-specific antitumor immune responses and an increase in immunosuppressive cellular responses.
■ THE NATURAL HISTORY OF HPV-ASSOCIATED
MALIGNANCY
HPV is transmitted by vaginal or anal intercourse, oral sex, and probably by touching a partner’s genitalia. In cross-sectional and longitudinal studies, ~40% of young women demonstrate evidence of HPV
infection, with peaks during the teens and early twenties, soon after
first coital experience. The number of lifetime sexual partners correlates with the likelihood of HPV infection and the subsequent risk of
HPV-associated malignancy. HPV infection may occur in a monogamous person if that person’s partner is infected.
Most HPV infections become undetectable after 6–9 months, a phenomenon known as “clearance.” However, with prolonged follow-up
and frequent sampling, the same HPV types may again be detected
months or even years later. It is still debated whether such episodic
detection indicates viral latency followed by reactivation or represents
reinfection with an identical HPV type.
While HPV is the causative agent of several cancers, most attention
has focused on cervical cancer, which is the second most common
cancer in women worldwide. More than 500,000 women are diagnosed
and 275,000 die from invasive cervical cancer annually. More than 85%
of all cervical cancer cases, as well as deaths, occur in women living in
low-income countries, especially countries in sub-Saharan Africa, Asia,
and South and Central America.
Evidence collected over 25 years shows that HPV causes nearly 100%
of cervical cancers. Persistent HPV infection is the most significant risk
factor for cervical cancer; relative risks range from 10 to 20 and exceed
100 in prospective and case–control studies, respectively. The time
from HPV infection to cervical cancer may exceed 20 years. Cervical
cancer peaks in the fifth and sixth decades of life for women living in
developed countries and as much as a decade earlier for women living
in resource-poor countries. Persistent carriers of oncogenic HPV types
are at greatest risk for high-grade cervical dysplasia and cancer.
Why HPV infections in some women but not others eventually
lead to malignancy is not clear. Although oncogenic HPV infection
is necessary for the development of cervical malignancy, only ~3–5%
1499CHAPTER 198 Human Papillomavirus Infections
■ CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS OF HPV INFECTION
HPV infects the male urethra, penis, and scrotum and the female vulva,
vagina, and cervix. Perianal, anal, and oropharyngeal infections occur
in both genders. Genital warts are caused primarily by HPV type 6
or 11 and appear as soft sessile growths with a surface that is either
smooth or rough with multiple finger-like projections. Penile genital
warts are usually 2–5 mm in diameter and often occur in groups. A
second type of penile lesion, the keratotic plaque, is slightly raised
above normal epithelium and has a rough, often pigmented surface.
Figs. 198-1–198-3 show vulvar and vaginal, penile, and perianal warts,
respectively.
Vulvar warts are soft, whitish papules that are either sessile or have
multiple fine, finger-like projections. These lesions are most often
located in the introitus and labia. In nonmucosal areas, vulvar lesions
are similar in appearance to those in men: dry and keratotic. Vulvar
lesions can appear as smooth, sometimes pigmented papules that may
coalesce. Vaginal lesions appear as multiple areas of elongated papillae.
Biopsy of vulvar or vaginal lesions may reveal malignancy; differentiation based on clinical exam is not always reliable.
Subclinical cervical HPV infections are common, and the cervix
may appear normal on examination. Cervical lesions often appear as
of infected women will ever develop this cancer, even in the absence
of cytologic screening. Biomarkers that can predict which women
will develop cervical cancer are not available. Immunosuppression
in general plays a significant role in redetection/reactivation of HPV
infections, while other factors, such as smoking, hormonal changes,
chlamydial infection, and nutritional deficits, have an impact on viral
persistence and cancer.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer has concluded
that HPV types 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, and 59 are
carcinogenic in the uterine cervix. HPV type 16 is particularly virulent
and causes 50% of cervical cancers. Worldwide, HPV types 16 and 18
cause at least 70% of cervical squamous cell carcinomas and 85% of
cervical adenocarcinomas. Oncogenic types other than 16 or 18 cause
the remaining 30% of cervical cancers. HPV types 16 and 18 also cause
nearly 90% of anal cancers worldwide.
In addition to cervical and anal cancer, other HPV-associated cancers include vulvar and vaginal cancer (caused by HPV in 50–70% of
cases), penile cancer (caused by HPV in 50% of cases), and at least
65% of oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinomas (OPSCCs). Over the
past two decades, an epidemic of OPSCC related to oncogenic HPV
infection, primarily HPV type 16, has developed. Rates of OPSCC
in the United States have been increasing in men from a low of 0.27
case per 100,000 in 1973 to 0.57 case per 100,000 per year in 2004;
rates in women have remained relatively stable at ~0.17 per 100,000
per year. The greatest increase in the incidence of OPSCC is among
white men 40–50 years of age. Nearly 14,000 new cases were diagnosed in the United States in 2013. OPSCCs of the base of the tongue
and tonsil cancer have increased annually by rates of 1.3 and 0.6%,
respectively. Few data are available from developing countries about
OPSCC.
■ THE EFFECTS OF HIV ON HPVASSOCIATED DISEASE
HIV infection accelerates the natural history of HPV infections.
HIV-infected individuals are more likely than other individuals to
develop genital warts, and their lesions are more recalcitrant to treatment. HIV infection has been consistently associated with precancerous cervical lesions, including low-grade cervical intraepithelial lesions
(CIN) and CIN 3, the immediate precursor to cervical cancer. Women
with HIV/AIDS have significantly higher rates of cervical cancer as
well as subsets of some vulvar, vaginal, and oropharyngeal tumors
(Chap. 70) than women in the general population. Studies indicate
a direct relationship between low CD4+ T lymphocyte count and the
risk of cervical cancer. Some studies show a reduced likelihood of
HPV infection and precancerous lesions of the cervix in HIV-infected
women given antiretroviral therapy (ART). However, the incidence of
cervical cancer in HIV-infected women has not changed significantly
since ART was introduced, possibly because of preexisting oncogenic
HPV infections that occurred before ART was initiated.
The burden of HPV-associated cancers is expected to increase in
HIV-infected patients, given the prolonged life expectancies provided
with ART. For women living in developing countries where cervical
cancer screening is not widely available, this trend will have significant
consequences. Thus, elucidating the interactions of HIV infection and
cervical cancer with cofactors such as diet, other sexually transmitted
infections, and environmental exposures is an important focus of research
that impacts women living in low- and middle-income countries.
Similar to that of cervical cancer, the incidence of anal cancer is
strongly influenced by HIV infection. HIV-infected men who have
sex with men (MSM) and HIV-infected women have much higher
rates of anal cancer than HIV-uninfected populations. Specifically, the
incidence among HIV-infected MSM has been found to be as high as
130 cases per 100,000, as opposed to 5 cases per 100,000 among HIVnegative MSM. The advent of ART has not impacted the incidence of
anal cancer and high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia in the HIVinfected patient population.
More information regarding screening, prevention, and treatment in
the HIV-infected population can be found at the Department of Health
and Human Services website (aidsinfo.nih.gov/guidelines).
FIGURE 198-1 Warts of the vulva and vagina caused by human papillomavirus.
(Reproduced with permission from K Wolff et al: Fitzpatrick’s Color Atlas and
Synopsis of Clinical Dermatology, 8th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2013.)
FIGURE 198-2 Penile genital warts caused by human papillomavirus. (Reproduced
with permission from K Wolff et al: Fitzpatrick’s Color Atlas and Synopsis of Clinical
Dermatology, 8th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2013.)
1500 PART 5 Infectious Diseases
papillary proliferations near the transformation zone. Irregular vascular loops are present beneath the surface epithelium. Patients who
develop cervical cancer from HPV infection may present with a variety
of symptoms. Early carcinomas appear eroded and bleed easily. More
advanced carcinomas present as ulcerated lesions or as an exophytic
cervical mass. Some cervical carcinomas are located in the cervical
canal and may be difficult to see. Bleeding, symptoms of a mass lesion
in late stages, and metastatic disease that may manifest as bowel or
bladder obstruction due to direct extension of the tumor have also
been described.
Patients with squamous cell cancer of the anus (Chap. 81) have
more variable presentations. The most common presentations include
rectal bleeding and pain or a mass sensation. Twenty percent of patients
who are diagnosed with anal cancer may not present with any specific
symptoms at the time of diagnosis, and the lesion is found fortuitously.
■ PREVENTION OF HPV INFECTION AND DISEASE
Behaviors That Can Reduce Exposure to HPV HPV infections are transmitted through direct contact with infected genital skin
or mucosal surfaces and secretions. Does abstinence reduce HPV
infections? For both men and women, numerous studies indicate that
HPV infection and HPV-associated diseases correlate with the number of lifetime sexual partners, and people with no history of sexual
intercourse have a lower detection rate of HPV. Fewer studies look
at nonpenetrative sex and the risk of HPV infection and disease, but
several studies indicate that HPV can be spread by any sexual intimacy,
including touching, oral sex, or use of sex toys. It is therefore possible
that individuals who have not partaken in penetrative sex can become
infected.
Use of latex condoms reduces the risk of HPV infection and
HPV-associated disease, such as genital warts and cervical precancers.
Correct and consistent condom use has also been associated with
regression of CIN in women and regression of HPV-associated penile
lesions in men. As a preventive measure, condom use should be considered partially effective at best and not a substitute for cervical cancer
screening or vaccination against HPV.
HPV Vaccines The development of HPV vaccines effective in
preventing infection and HPV-associated disease represents a major
development in the past decade. The vaccines use virus-like particles
(VLPs) that consist of the HPV L1 major capsid protein. The L1 protein
self-assembles into VLPs when expressed in eukaryotic cells (i.e., yeast
or insect cells). These VLPs contain the same epitopes as actual HPV
virions. However, they do not contain genetic material and therefore
cannot transmit infection. The immunogenicity of the HPV vaccines
relies on development of conformational neutralizing antibodies
directed toward epitopes displayed on viral capsids.
Several large vaccine trials have been completed and demonstrate
the high degree of safety and efficacy of HPV vaccines. There have
been three HPV vaccines developed, tested, and U.S. Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) approved, as described below.
BIVALENT VACCINE (CERVARIX) The bivalent HPV vaccine contains
L1 VLPs of HPV types 16 and 18 and is marketed under the name of
Cervarix (GlaxoSmithKline). This vaccine was tested in 18,644 women
15−25 years of age residing in the United States, South America, Europe,
and Asia. It is administered by intramuscular injection three times
(months 0, 1, and 6). The primary endpoints of the study included
vaccine efficacy against persistent infections with HPV types 16 and
18. Investigators also assessed vaccine efficacy against CIN grade 2 or
higher due to HPV 16 and 18 in women who had no evidence of HPV
16 or 18 infection at baseline. Vaccine efficacy related to HPV 16 or
HPV 18 was 94.9% (95% confidence interval [CI], 87.7–98.4%) against
CIN 2 or worse; 91.7% (95% CI, 66.6–99.1%) against CIN 3 or worse;
and 100% (95% CI, –8.6–100%) against adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS).
Adverse events associated with the bivalent vaccine were evaluated in
phase 3 trials in a subset of 3077 women who received vaccine and
3080 women who received hepatitis A vaccine. Injection-site adverse
events (pain, redness, and swelling) and systemic adverse events
(fatigue, headache, and myalgia) were reported more frequently in
the HPV vaccine group than in the control group. Serious adverse
events, new-onset chronic disease, or medically significant conditions
occurred in the same proportion (3.5%) of HPV vaccine recipients and
control vaccine recipients. The bivalent HPV vaccine is approved in
the United States for prevention of cervical cancer, CIN2 or worse, AIS,
and CIN 1 caused by HPV types 16 and 18. This vaccine is approved
for females 9−25 years of age. Cervarix is not currently marketed in
the United States.
QUADRIVALENT VACCINE (GARDASIL) The quadrivalent L1 VLP
vaccine (HPV types 6, 11, 16, and 18) is marketed under the name
Gardasil (Merck). It is administered intramuscularly three times
(months 0, 2, and 6). A combined efficacy analysis based on data
from four randomized double-blind clinical studies including >20,000
participants was performed; results demonstrated that vaccine efficacy against external genital warts was 98.9% (95% CI, 93.7−100%).
Vaccine efficacy was 95.2% (95% CI, 87.2−98.7%) against CIN; 100%
(95% CI, 92.9−100%) against type 16- or 18-related CIN 2/3 or AIS;
and 100% (95% CI, 55.5−100.0%) against type 16- or 18-related vulvar
intraepithelial neoplasia grades 2 and 3 (VIN 2/3) and against vaginal
intraepithelial neoplasia grades 2 and 3 (VaIN 2/3).
Safety data on the quadrivalent HPV vaccine are available from
seven clinical trials, including nearly 12,000 women 9−26 years of
age who received the vaccine and ~10,000 women who received
aluminum-containing or saline placebo. A larger proportion of young
women reported injection-site adverse events in the vaccine groups
than in the placebo groups. Systemic adverse events were reported
by similar proportions of vaccine and placebo recipients and were
described as mild or moderate for most participants. The types of
serious adverse events reported were similar for the two groups. Ten
persons who received the quadrivalent vaccine and seven persons who
received placebo died during the course of the trials; no deaths were
considered to be vaccine related.
During the course of studies on the quadrivalent HPV vaccine,
surveillance data for development of new medical conditions were
collected for up to 4 years after vaccination. No statistically significant
differences in the incidence of any medical conditions between vaccine
and placebo recipients were demonstrated; this result indicated a very
high safety profile for the vaccine. A recent safety review by the FDA
and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) examined events related to Gardasil that had been reported to the Vaccine
Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS). The adverse events were
FIGURE 198-3 Perianal warts caused by human papillomavirus. (Reproduced with
permission from K Wolff et al: Fitzpatrick’s Color Atlas and Synopsis of Clinical
Dermatology, 8th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2013.)
1501CHAPTER 198 Human Papillomavirus Infections
consistent with what was seen in previous safety studies of the vaccine.
Of note, rates of syncope and venous thrombotic events were higher
with Gardasil than those usually observed with other vaccines.
The quadrivalent HPV vaccine is approved for (1) vaccination of
females ages 9−26 years of age to prevent genital warts and cervical
cancer caused by HPV types 6, 11, 16, and 18; (2) vaccination of
the same population to prevent precancerous or dysplastic lesions,
including cervical AIS, CIN 2/3, VIN 2/3, VaIN 2/3, and CIN 1; (3)
vaccination of males 9−26 years of age to prevent genital warts caused
by HPV types 6 and 11; and (4) vaccination of people ages 9−26 years
to prevent anal cancer and associated precancerous lesions due to HPV
types 6, 11, 16, and 18. While the duration of protection has not been
established, no evidence of waning protection has been found after a
three-dose series of the quadrivalent HPV vaccine, even after 10 years
of follow-up from clinical trials. The quadrivalent HPV vaccine is no
longer available in the United States but is still available in many other
countries, although production is not likely to continue in the future.
NINE-VALENT VACCINE (GARDASIL-9) In 2014, the FDA approved a
new nine-valent L1 VLP vaccine. The nine-valent vaccine is marketed
under the name Gardasil-9 (Merck). It is administered intramuscularly
three times (months 0, 2, and 6). The nine-valent vaccine targets HPV
types 6, 11, 16, and 18 (the types also targeted by the quadrivalent HPV
vaccine) as well as five additional oncogenic HPV types (31, 33, 45, 52,
and 58). HPV types 16 and 18 together cause up to 80% of all cervical
cancers worldwide, and worldwide data show that HPV types 31, 33, 35,
45, 52, and 58 are the next most frequently detected types in invasive cervical cancers. Mathematical models estimate that the level of protection
conferred by the nine-valent HPV vaccine against all HPV-associated
squamous cell cancers worldwide could be raised to 90%.
In clinical studies of females 16−26 years of age, the nine-valent
HPV vaccine generated a noninferior antibody response to HPV types
6, 11, 16, and 18 compared to the quadrivalent HPV vaccine. Bridging
immunologic studies in male and female vaccine recipients 9−15 years
of age and in males 16−26 years of age indicated that the lower bound
of the 95% CIs of the geometric mean titer ratio and seroconversion
rates met criteria for noninferiority for all HPV types represented in
the vaccine. In female recipients 16−26 years of age, vaccine efficacy
against the combined endpoint of high-grade cervical, vulvar, or vaginal disease caused by any of the five additional oncogenic HPV types
was 96.7% (95% CI, 80.9–99.8%). Like the other available HPV vaccines, the nine-valent HPV vaccine is safe and extremely well tolerated.
The nine-valent HPV vaccine has an FDA indication for prevention
of cervical, vaginal, vulvar, and anal cancer and genital warts due to
vaccine types.
CROSS-PROTECTION OF HPV VACCINES Women who receive any
of the available HPV vaccines produce neutralizing antibodies to
virus types that are closely related to type 16 or 18. Analyses of data
from clinical trials suggest that the HPV vaccines may offer limited
cross-protection against nonvaccine virus types. Over short periods,
the bivalent vaccine appears more efficacious against HPV types 31, 33,
and 45 than the quadrivalent vaccine, but differences in study design
make direct comparisons difficult, if not impossible. In addition, in
the bivalent vaccine trials, vaccine efficacy against persistent infections
with HPV types 31 and 45 waned over time, whereas efficacy against
persistent infection with HPV type 16 or 18 remained stable. These
results suggest that cross-protection is likely to be shorter lived than
efficacy against infection and disease caused by vaccine types.
TWO-DOSE VERSUS THREE-DOSE SCHEDULE FOR HPV VACCINATION In an effort to simplify the dosing schedule and potentially
reduce costs and improve vaccine uptake, a two-dose schedule has been
considered. In several randomized vaccine trials among adolescent
girls, geometric mean concentrations (GMCs) of antibodies to HPV
type 16 were shown to be noninferior up to 24 months after a two-dose
schedule to GMCs after a three-dose schedule. Numerous countries
have adopted a two-dose HPV vaccination schedule. In the United
States, the CDC now recommends two doses of HPV vaccine (at 0
and 6−12 months) for persons starting the vaccination series before
the fifteenth birthday, as the immunologic response is rigorous in this
age group. Three doses of HPV vaccine (at 0, 1−2, and 6 months) are
recommended for persons starting the vaccination series on or after the
fifteenth birthday and for persons with certain immunocompromising
conditions, including HIV/AIDS.
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR HPV VACCINATION The most recent guidelines for HPV vaccination from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) are summarized below and provided in detail
at https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/68/wr/mm6832a3.htm.
No prevaccination testing of any kind is recommended to establish
whether or not the HPV vaccine should be administered to an individual to determine if the vaccine will or will not be effective. The HPV
vaccine should be administered, if possible, before exposure to HPV
through sexual activity because the vaccines are preventative against
specific HPV types and have no effect on preexisting, type-specific
HPV infections. Either the bivalent (where available) or nine-valent
HPV vaccines may be used. An individual can begin a vaccine series
with one HPV vaccine and then complete the series with another. For
those who have completed a vaccination series with the bivalent or
quadrivalent vaccine, an additional full series (three doses) of vaccination with the nine-valent vaccine may be given, but there are no data
to determine the effectiveness of this approach.
For children, adolescents, and adults (male and female) 9−26 years
of age, the ACIP recommends HPV vaccination at age 11 or 12 years,
although vaccination can be initiated at 9 years of age. “Catch-up” HPV
vaccination is recommended for men and women through 26 years of
age who are not adequately vaccinated.
For adults (male and female) 27−45 years of age, catch-up HPV
vaccination is not routinely recommended. Instead, the ACIP now recommends shared clinical decision-making regarding HPV vaccination
for certain adults 27−45 years of age who are not adequately vaccinated
(see below). HPV vaccines are not licensed for use in adults older than
45 years of age. For women, cervical cancer screening should continue
according to age-specific guidelines regardless of having received an
HPV vaccine (see cervical cancer screening section below).
SHARED CLINICAL DECISION-MAKING FOR ADULTS 27−45 YEARS OF
AGE A discussion with adults 27−45 years of age should occur prior
to routine recommendation of the HPV vaccine. HPV infection occurs
soon after first sexual activity in most people, and vaccine effectiveness
is therefore lower in older individuals due to prior infections. HPV
exposure usually decreases among older age groups. Although HPV
vaccination is safe for adults 27−45 years of age, the benefit to the population is likely to be minimal. However, some men and women who
are not vaccinated may be at risk for acquisition of new HPV infections
and could therefore benefit from HPV vaccination.
In considering HPV vaccination of adults 27−45 years of age, some
key points emphasized by the ACIP that should be discussed include
the following:
• HPV is a common sexually transmitted infection, and most HPV
infections are asymptomatic and do not lead to clinical disease.
• Most sexually active adults have been exposed to HPV, although not
necessarily all of the HPV types targeted by vaccines.
• Some adults are at risk for acquiring new HPV infections through
sexual activity. For example, having a new sex partner is a risk factor
for acquiring a new HPV infection.
• Persons in a long-term, mutually monogamous sexual partnership
are unlikely to acquire a new HPV infection.
• Antibody testing cannot determine whether a person is immune or
susceptible to a specific HPV type.
• HPV vaccines are very effective in persons who have not been
exposed to vaccine-type HPV before vaccination.
• Vaccine effectiveness is likely to be lower among persons with multiple lifetime sex partners because these individuals have probably
had previous infections with vaccine-type HPV.
• HPV vaccines are prophylactic (i.e., they prevent new HPV infections). They have no utility in preventing established HPV infection
from progressing to clinical disease, and they do not have a role in
treatment of HPV-associated disease.
1502 PART 5 Infectious Diseases
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR HPV VACCINATION IN PEOPLE LIVING WITH
HIV (PLWH) Guidelines for HPV vaccination of PLWH are summarized below and can be found in detail at https://aidsinfo.nih.gov/
guidelines/html/4/adult-and-adolescent-opportunistic-infection/343/
human-papillomavirus.
HPV vaccines are safe in PLWH. Administration of HPV vaccines
generates high levels of antibody against HPV types represented in
vaccine, although antibody levels are generally lower than in those
who are HIV-uninfected. In addition, immune responses appear stronger among PLWH who have the highest CD4 counts and the lowest
HIV viral loads. Studies also indicate that HPV vaccination induces
an anamnestic response in PLWH. Regarding efficacy in protecting
against HPV-associated disease, one randomized, double-blind, clinical trial evaluated the efficacy of the quadrivalent HPV vaccine in
adults with HIV infection older than 27 years in prevention of new anal
HPV infections or improvement in high-grade dysplastic anal lesions.
The trial did not show efficacy, but study participants had high levels
of HPV infection at baseline.
HPV vaccination is recommended for girls and boys with HIV
infection 11−26 years of age. Because some individuals with HIV
infection (similar to HIV-uninfected individuals) have had many sex
partners prior to vaccination, HPV vaccination may be less beneficial
in these patients than in those with few or no lifetime sex partners.
Current data do not support vaccination for those PLWH older than
26 years. The public health benefit for HPV vaccination of PLWH in
this age range is likely to be minimal. However, although most PLWH
ages 27–45 years will not benefit from the vaccine, there may be situations that suggest the possibility of vaccine benefit, and the same
shared clinical decision-making (described above) between the provider and patient is recommended.
■ SCREENING FOR HPV-ASSOCIATED CANCER
Once HPV infection occurs, prevention of HPV-associated disease
relies on screening. At present, screening for cervical cancer is widely
accepted as cost-effective in preventing cervical cancer. Anal screening
is accepted for screening in high-risk groups, though no national guidelines exist for screening intervals or ages for initiation and cessation of
screening. In resource-rich countries, the primary method of cervical
cancer screening is cytology via Pap smear. The American Society of
Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology (ASCCP) guidelines recommend
initiation of cervical cancer screening at age 21, no matter the age of
sexual debut. Women 21−29 years old should have a Pap smear every
3 years if their initial and subsequent Pap smears are normal. Although
adolescent and young women often test HPV DNA-positive, they are
at very low risk of cervical cancer. Because the presence of HPV DNA
does not correlate with the presence of high-grade squamous intraepithelial neoplasia, co-testing (testing for HPV DNA at the time of Pap
smear) is not recommended for women in this age group.
As a method of determining the need for colposcopy, HPV DNA
co-testing is recommended for women 25−29 years of age in whom
cytology detects abnormal squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS). Women 30−65 should have a Pap smear every 3 years
if testing for HPV DNA is not performed. The screening interval for
women in this age group can be extended to every 5 years if HPV DNA
co-testing is performed and results are negative. HPV testing is not
recommended for partners of women with HPV or for screening of
conditions other than cervical cancer.
The role of HPV DNA testing as a primary screen for cervical cancer
is changing. In the United States, there are two commercially available
assays (cobas HPV Test [Roche Diagnostics] and the BD Onclarity
HPV Assay [Becton, Dickinson and Company]) that are FDA approved
for primary screening using HPV DNA testing. However, more assays
may gain approval for usage as the feasibility and evidence for their use
in various populations globally come to light. These tests can be used
to detect HPV DNA in specimens obtained from the cervix without
cervical cytology for women ≥25 years of age. A positive result for HPV
type 16 or 18 has a high enough positive predictive value in the general
population that these women should have colposcopy performed. If
high-risk HPV types are detected other than HPV 16 or HPV 18, then
cytology can be obtained. The complete set of algorithms for appropriate age-specific screening guidelines, HPV DNA testing, and the
management of abnormal Pap smears are available through the ASCCP
at http://asccp.org/guidelines.
For women ≤30 years of age who are infected with HIV, cervical
cytology is the preferred method of cervical cancer screening and
HPV DNA co-testing is not recommended. Cervical cancer screening
should begin within 1 year of diagnosis of HIV infection, regardless
of the mode of HIV transmission. If the first Pap smear is normal,
then subsequent Pap smears should be performed annually until
three negative tests are obtained. Cytology can then be obtained every
3 years. For women ≥30 years old, Pap testing is performed in the same
manner as for younger women. However, HPV DNA co-testing can be
used in women of this age group. If cytology and HPV DNA co-testing
are negative, the next exam can be performed in 3 years. Positive HPV
DNA co-test results are treated in the same manner as in HIV-uninfected
women.
Women residing in developing countries with a lack of access to
cervical screening programs have a higher rate of cervical cancer and
a poorer cancer-specific survival. Approximately 75% of women living in developed countries have been screened in the past 5 years, as
opposed to ~5% of women living in developing countries. Economic
and logistic obstacles likely impede routine cervical cancer screening
for these populations. Many poor countries rely on an alternative
method—visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA)—for cervical cancer
screening. While some studies show a reduction in cervical cancer
mortality in communities where VIA is widely utilized, other studies
do not. In addition, the low specificity of VIA is problematic. As newer
methods that use detection of oncogenic HPV DNA become available,
even resource-limited countries may be able to replace VIA with such
methods and achieve a reduction in cervical cancers as a result.
Currently, there is no broad consensus regarding the screening for
anal cancer and its precursors, including high-grade anal intraepithelial lesions. The reason is a lack of understanding of optimal treatment
for low- or high-grade anal dysplasia found during cytologic screening.
Current HIV treatment guidelines suggest that there may be a benefit
to screening, but an effect on the associated morbidity and mortality
of anal squamous cell cancer has not been consistently demonstrated.
The incidence of HPV-associated head and neck cancers in the United
States has overtaken the incidence of cervical cancer as of 2020, but
there are no established guidelines for screening for HPV-associated
head and neck cancers. However, HPV vaccination is likely to be
effective for both anal and head and neck cancers associated with HPV.
TREATMENT
HPV-Associated Disease
A variety of treatment modalities are available for various HPV
infections, but none has been proven to eliminate HPV from
tissue adjacent to the destroyed and infected tissue. Treatment
efficacies are limited by frequent recurrences, presumably due to
reinfection from an infected partner, reactivation of latent virus, or
autoinoculation from nearby infected cells. The goals of treatment
include prevention of viral transmission, eradication of premalignant lesions, and reduction of symptoms.
Therapies are generally successful in eliminating visible lesions
and grossly diseased tissue. Different therapies are indicated for
genital warts, vaginal and cervical disease, and perianal and anal
disease.
THERAPEUTIC OPTIONS
Imiquimod Imiquimod (5 or 3.75% cream) is a patient-applied
topical immunomodulatory agent thought to activate immune
cells by binding to a Toll-like receptor that leads to an inflammatory response. Imiquimod 5% cream is applied to genital warts
at bedtime three times per week for up to 16 weeks. Warts are
cleared in ~56% of patients, more often in women than in men;
recurrence rates approach 13%. Local inflammatory side effects are
No comments:
Post a Comment
اكتب تعليق حول الموضوع