3614 PART 14 Poisoning, Drug Overdose, and Envenomation
Large local reactions accompanied by erythema, edema, warmth,
and tenderness that spread ≥10 cm around the sting site over 1–2 days
are not uncommon. These reactions may resemble bacterial cellulitis
but are caused by hypersensitivity rather than by secondary infection. Such reactions tend to recur on subsequent exposure but are
seldom accompanied by anaphylaxis and are not prevented by venom
immunotherapy.
An estimated 0.4–4.0% of the U.S. population exhibits clinical
immediate-type hypersensitivity to hymenopteran stings, and 15% may
have asymptomatic sensitization manifested by positive skin tests. Persons who experience severe allergic reactions are likely to have similar
or more severe reactions after subsequent stings by the same or closely
related species. Mild anaphylactic reactions to insect stings, as to other
causes, consist of nausea, abdominal cramping, generalized urticaria or
angioedema, and flushing. Serious reactions, including upper airway
edema, bronchospasm, hypotension, and shock, may be rapidly fatal.
Severe reactions usually begin within 10 min of the sting and only
rarely develop after 5 h.
TREATMENT
Bee and Wasp Stings
Honeybee stingers embedded in the skin should be removed as
soon as possible to limit the quantity of venom delivered. The
stinger and venom sac may be scraped off with a blade, a fingernail,
or the edge of a credit card or may be removed with forceps. The site
should be cleansed and disinfected and ice packs applied to slow the
spread of venom. Elevation of the affected site and administration
of oral analgesics, oral antihistamines, and topical calamine lotion
help relieve symptoms.
Anaphylactic reactions to bee or wasp venom can be a
life-threatening emergency that requires prompt life-saving actions.
If the individual carries a bee-sting kit, then a subcutaneous injection of epinephrine hydrochloride (0.3 mL of a 1:1000 dilution)
should be considered, with treatment repeated every 20–30 min as
necessary. A tourniquet may slow the spread of venom. The patient
should be transferred to a hospital emergency room where treatment for profound shock, if required, can be administered safely.
Such treatment may entail the use of IV epinephrine and other
vasopressors, intubation or provision of supplemental oxygen, fluid
resuscitation, use of bronchodilators, and parenteral administration
of antihistamines. Patients should be observed for 24 h for recurrent
anaphylaxis, renal failure, or coagulopathy.
Persons with a history of allergy to insect stings should carry an
anaphylaxis kit with a preloaded syringe containing epinephrine for
self-administration. These patients should seek medical attention
immediately after using the kit.
Prophylactic immunotherapy may greatly reduce the risk of
life-threatening reactions to bee and wasp stings. Repeated injections of purified venom produce a blocking IgG antibody response
to venom and reduce the incidence of recurrent anaphylaxis. Honeybee, wasp, and yellow jacket venoms are commercially available
for desensitization and for skin testing. Results of skin tests and
venom-specific radioallergosorbent tests (RASTs) aid in the selection of patients for immunotherapy and guide the design of such
treatment.
■ STINGING ANTS
Stinging ants are an important medical problem in the United States.
Imported fire ants (Solenopsis species) infest southern states from Texas
to North Carolina, with colonies now established in California, New
Mexico, Arizona, and Virginia. Slight disturbances of their mound
nests have provoked massive outpourings of ants and as many as 10,000
stings on a single person. Elderly and immobile persons are at high risk
for attacks when fire ants invade dwellings.
Fire ants attach to skin with powerful mandibles and rotate their
bodies while repeatedly injecting venom with posteriorly situated
stingers. The alkaloid venom consists of cytotoxic and hemolytic
piperidines and several proteins with enzymatic activity. The initial
wheal-and-flare reaction, burning, and itching resolve in ~30 min,
and a sterile pustule develops within 24 h. The pustule ulcerates over
the next 48 h and then heals in ≥1 week. Large areas of erythema and
edema lasting several days are not uncommon and, in extreme cases,
may compress nerves and blood vessels. Anaphylaxis occurs in <2%
of victims; seizures and mononeuritis have been reported. Stings are
treated with ice packs, topical glucocorticoids, and oral antihistamines.
Pustules should be cleansed and then covered with bandages and antibiotic ointment to prevent bacterial infection. Epinephrine administration and supportive measures are indicated for anaphylactic reactions.
Fire ant whole-body extracts are available for skin testing and immunotherapy, which appear to lower the rate of anaphylactic reactions.
European fire (red) ants (Myrmica rubra) have recently become public health pests in the northeastern United States and southern Canada.
The western United States is home to harvester ants (Pogonomyrmex
species). The painful local reaction that follows harvester ant stings
often extends to lymph nodes and may be accompanied by anaphylaxis. The bullet or conga ant (Paraponera clavata) of South America
is known locally as hormiga veinticuatro (“24-hour ant”), a designation
that refers to the 24 h of throbbing, excruciating pain following a sting
that delivers the potent paralyzing neurotoxin poneratoxin.
■ DIPTERAN (FLY AND MOSQUITO) BITES
In the process of feeding on vertebrate blood and tissue fluids, adults of
certain fly species inflict painful bites, inject saliva that may cause vasodilation and produce local allergic reactions, and may transmit diverse
pathogenic agents. Bites of mosquitoes (culicids), tiny “no-see-um”
midges (ceratopogonids), and sand flies (phlebotomines) typically
produce a wheal and a pruritic papule. Small humpbacked black flies
(simuliids) lacerate skin, resulting in a lesion with serosanguineous
discharge that is often painful and pruritic. Regional lymphadenopathy, fever, or anaphylaxis occasionally ensues. The widely distributed
deerflies and horseflies as well as the tsetse flies of Africa are stout
flies that attack during the day and produce large and painful bleeding
punctures. House flies (Musca domestica) do not consume blood but
use rasping mouthparts to scarify skin and feed upon tissue fluids and
salt. Beyond direct injury from bites of any kind of fly, risks include
transmission of diverse pathogens and secondary bacterial infection
of the lesion.
TREATMENT
Fly and Mosquito Bites
Treatment of fly bites is symptom based. Topical application of
antipruritic agents, glucocorticoids, or antiseptic lotions may relieve
itching and pain. Allergic reactions may require oral antihistamines. Antibiotics may be necessary for the treatment of large bite
wounds that become secondarily infected.
■ FLEA BITES
Common human-biting fleas include the dog and cat fleas (Ctenocephalides species) and the rat flea (Xenopsylla cheopis), which infest
their respective hosts and their nests and resting sites. Sensitized
persons develop erythematous pruritic papules (papular urticaria) and
occasionally vesicles and bacterial superinfection at the site of the bite.
Symptom-based treatment consists of antihistamines, topical glucocorticoids, and topical antipruritic agents.
Flea infestations are eliminated by removal and treatment of animal
nests, frequent cleaning of pet bedding, and application of contact
and systemic insecticides to pets and the dwelling. Flea infestations
in the home may be abated or prevented if pets are regularly treated
with veterinary antiparasitic agents, insect growth regulators, or chitin
inhibitors.
Tunga penetrans, like other fleas, is a wingless, laterally flattened
insect that feeds on blood. Also known as the chigoe flea, sand flea,
3615Ectoparasite Infestations and Arthropod Injuries CHAPTER 461
or jigger (not to be confused with the chigger), it occurs in tropical
regions of Africa and the Americas. Adult female chigoes live in sandy
soil and burrow under the skin, usually between toes, under nails, or
on the soles of bare feet. Gravid chigoes engorge on the host’s blood
and grow from pinpoint to pea size during a 2-week interval. They
produce lesions that resemble a white pustule with a central black
depression and that may be pruritic or painful. Occasional complications include tetanus, bacterial infections, and autoamputation of
toes (ainhum). Tungiasis is treated by removal of the intact flea with
a sterile needle or scalpel, tetanus vaccination, and topical application
of antibiotics.
■ HEMIPTERAN/HETEROPTERAN (TRUE BUG)
BITES
Most true bugs feed on plants, but some are predaceous or feed on
blood. In order to feed or to defend themselves, they may inflict bites
that produce allergic reactions and are sometimes painful. Bites of the
cone-nose or “kissing bugs” (family Reduviidae) tend to occur at night
and are painless. Reactions to such bites depend on prior sensitization
and include tender and pruritic papules, vesicular or bullous lesions,
extensive urticaria, fever, lymphadenopathy, and (rarely) anaphylaxis.
Bug bites are treated with topical antipruritic agents or oral antihistamines. Persons with anaphylactic reactions to reduviid bites should
keep an epinephrine kit available. Some reduviids transmit Trypanosoma cruzi, the agent of New World trypanosomiasis (Chagas disease)
(Chap. 227).
The cosmopolitan and tropical bed bugs (Cimex lectularius and
C. hemipterus) hide in crevices of mattresses, bed frames and other
furniture, walls, and picture frames and under loose wallpaper, actively
seeking blood meals at night. These bugs are now a common pest in
homes, dormitories, and hotels; on cruise ships; and even in medical
facilities. Their bite is painless. Bites on persons without prior exposure
to bedbugs may not be noticeable. Persons sensitized to bed bug saliva
develop erythema, itching, and wheals around a central hemorrhagic
punctum. Reactions may manifest within minutes of the bites, or they
may be delayed for days or even a week or more. Bed bugs are not
known to transmit pathogens.
■ CENTIPEDE BITES AND MILLIPEDE DERMATITIS
Two groups of myriapods (“many-footed” arthropods) can harm
humans. Centipedes, with one pair of legs per body segment, are
fast-moving, aggressive, and carnivorous. They stun and kill their
prey—usually other arthropods, earthworms, and rarely small
vertebrates—with a venomous bite. The fangs of centipedes of the
genus Scolopendra can penetrate human skin and deliver a venom
that produces intense burning pain, swelling, erythema, and sterile
lymphangitis. Dizziness, nausea, and anxiety are described occasionally, and rhabdomyolysis and renal failure have been reported. Treatment includes washing of the site, application of cold dressings, oral
analgesic administration or local lidocaine infiltration, and tetanus
prophylaxis.
Millipedes, with two pairs of legs per segment, are slow-moving,
docile, and feed mostly on decaying plant materials. They do not bite,
but some secrete defensive fluids that may burn and discolor human
skin. Affected skin turns brown overnight and may blister and exfoliate. Secretions in the eye cause intense pain and inflammation that
can result in corneal ulcers and even blindness. Management includes
irrigation with copious amounts of water or saline, use of analgesics,
and local care of denuded skin.
■ CATERPILLAR STINGS AND DERMATITIS
Caterpillars of several moth species are covered with hairs or spines
that produce mechanical irritation and may contain or be coated with
venom. Contact with these caterpillars or their hairs may lead to erucism (a pruritic urticarial or papular rash) or caterpillar envenomation.
The response typically consists of an immediate burning sensation
followed by local swelling and erythema and occasionally by regional
lymphadenopathy, nausea, vomiting, and headache. A rare reaction to
a South American caterpillar, Lonomia obliqua, can cause disseminated
coagulopathy and fatal hemorrhagic shock.
Dermatitis is most often associated with caterpillars of io, puss,
saddleback, and browntail moths in North America and with the oak
processionary moth in Europe. Even contact with detached hairs of
other caterpillars, such as gypsy moth larvae, can later produce erucism. Spines may be deposited on tree trunks or drying laundry or may
be airborne and cause irritation of the eyes and upper airways. Treatment of caterpillar stings consists of repeated application of adhesive
or cellophane tape to remove the hairs, which can then be identified
microscopically. Local ice packs, topical glucocorticoids, and oral antihistamines relieve symptoms.
Few adult moths cause human health problems. Adult yellowtail
moths (Hylesia species), found mainly in coastal mangrove zones along
the eastern coast of Central and South America, have bodies that are
covered by fine hairs or setae. The hairs on the ventral surface can
detach and, when in contact with human skin, cause an extremely pruritic reaction called “Carapito itch.” This issue is especially problematic
when the moths have population booms, creating swarms around
coastal communities.
■ BEETLE VESICATION AND DERMATITIS
Several families of beetles have independently developed the ability to
produce chemically unrelated vesicating toxins. When disturbed, blister beetles (family Meloidae) exude cantharidin, a low-molecular-weight
toxin that produces thin-walled blisters (≤5 cm in diameter) 2–5 h after
contact. The blisters are not painful or pruritic unless broken. They
resolve without treatment in ≤10 days. Nephritis may follow unusually
heavy cantharidin exposure.
The hemolymph of certain rove beetles (Paederus species, Staphylinidae family) contains pederin, a potent vesicant. When these beetles are
crushed or brushed against the skin, the released fluid causes painful,
red, flaccid bullae. These beetles occur worldwide but are most numerous and problematic in parts of Africa (where they are called “Nairobi
fly”) and southwestern Asia. Ocular lesions may develop after impact
with flying beetles at night or unintentional transfer of the vesicant on
the fingers. Treatment is rarely necessary, although ruptured blisters
should be kept clean and bandaged.
Larvae of common carpet beetles are adorned with dense arrays
of ornate hairs called hastisetae. Contact with these larvae or their
setae results in delayed dermal reactions in sensitized individuals. The
lesions are commonly mistaken for bites of bed bugs.
■ DELUSIONAL INFESTATIONS
The groundless conviction that one is infested with arthropods or
other parasites (Ekbom syndrome, delusory parasitosis, delusions of
parasitosis, and perhaps Morgellons syndrome) is extremely difficult
to treat and, unfortunately, is not uncommon (Fig. 461-2). Patients
describe uncomfortable sensations of something moving in or on their
skin. Excoriations and self-induced ulcerations typically accompany
the pruritus, dysesthesias, and imaginary insect bites. Patients often
believe that some invisible or as yet undescribed creatures are infesting
their skin, clothing, homes, or environment in general. Frequently,
patients submit as evidence of infestation specimens that consist of
plant-feeding and nonbiting peridomestic arthropods, pieces of skin,
vegetable matter, lint, and other inanimate detritus. In the evaluation of
a patient with possible delusional parasitosis, it is imperative to rule out
true infestations and bites by arthropods, endocrinopathies, sensory
disorders due to neuropathies, opiate and other drug use, environmental irritants (e.g., fiberglass threads), and other causes of tingling or
prickling sensations. Frequently, such patients repeatedly seek medical
consultations, resist alternative explanations for their symptoms, and
exacerbate their discomfort by self-treatment. Long-term pharmacotherapy with pimozide or other psychotropic agents has been more
helpful than psychotherapy in treating this disorder. Patients with delusory parasitosis often develop the unshakeable conviction that they are
infested by a previously unknown pathogen, while their personal lives,
family support, and employment collapse around them.
3616 PART 14 Poisoning, Drug Overdose, and Envenomation
■ FURTHER READING
Arlia LG, Morgan MS: A review of Sarcoptes scabiei: Past, present
and future. Parasit Vectors 10:297, 2017.
Goddard J: Infectious Diseases and Arthropods, 3rd ed. Totowa, NJ,
Humana Press, 2018.
Hinkle N: Ekbom syndrome: The challenge of “invisible bug” infestations. Annu Rev Entomol 55:77, 2010.
Mathison BA, Pritt BS : Laboratory identification of arthropod ectoparasites. Clin Microbiol Rev 27:48, 2014.
McGraw TA, Turiansky MC: Cutaneous myiasis. J Am Acad Dermatol 58:907, 2008.
Moraru GM, Goddard J II: The Goddard Guide to Arthropods of
Medical Importance, 7th ed. Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, 2019.
Mullen G, Durden L: Medical and Veterinary Entomology, 2nd ed.
Amsterdam, Academic Press, 2009.
Pollack RJ, Marcus L: A travel medicine guide to arthropods of
medical importance. Infect Dis Clin North Am 19:169, 2005.
Richards SL et al: Do tick attachment times vary between different
tick–pathogen systems? Environments 4:37, 2017.
Ryan NM et al: Treatments for latrodectism—A systematic review on
their clinical effectiveness. Toxins 9:148, 2017.
Saucier JR: Arachnid envenomation. Emerg Med Clin North Am
22:405, 2004.
Steen CJ et al: Insect sting reactions to bees, wasps, and ants. Int J
Dermatol 44:91, 2005.
Thomas C et al: Ectoparasites: Scabies. J Am Acad Dermatol 82:533,
2020.
Vetter RS, Isbister GK: Medical aspects of spider bites. Annu Rev
Entomol 53:409, 2008.
FIGURE 461-2 Real (left) versus delusional (right) infestation: comparable images of the lower backs of two young adults with multiple lesions. Left: A young woman
developed innumerable widespread lesions during a camping ecotour near Manaus, Brazil. Note scattered clusters of irregularly spaced lesions, accompanied by dozens
of single or isolated lesions, consistent with the semi-random feeding pattern of biting flies. Lesions appear to be in roughly the same stage of development, a feature
indicating that they were acquired at roughly the same time. No lesions were present before her ecotour; none have arisen since. This patient scratches the intensely
pruritic lesions and causes superficial erosions. Unexcoriated lesions are also present on her midback, where she cannot scratch. Right: A young man has innumerable
widespread lesions that have accumulated for several years, with a few new lesions appearing several times a week. His lesions are in various stages of development
(fresh, crusted, re-epithelialized, pigmented, and scarred), a feature indicating a long-standing process. The lesions are distributed in a regular pattern consistent with
periodic “excavations” to remove alleged parasites that he believes are crawling through his skin. Scarring is due to manipulations that create dermal ulcers rather than
superficial excoriations and erosions. Parts of his upper midback, where he cannot scratch, are free of lesions.
Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures PART 15
462
■ EPIDEMIOLOGY
Mountains cover one-fifth of the earth’s surface; 140 million people
live permanently at altitudes ≥2500 m, and 100 million people travel to
high-altitude locations each year. Skiers in the Alps or Aspen; tourists
to La Paz, Ladakh, or Lahsa; religious pilgrims to Kailash-Manasarovar
or Gosainkunda; trekkers and climbers to Kilimanjaro, Aconcagua, or
Everest; miners working in high-altitude sites in South America; and
military personnel deployed to high-altitude locations are all at risk
of developing acute mountain sickness (AMS), high-altitude cerebral
edema (HACE), high-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE), and other
altitude-related problems. AMS is the benign form of altitude illness,
whereas HACE and HAPE are life-threatening. Altitude illness is likely
to occur above 2500 m but has been documented even at 1500–2500 m.
In the Mount Everest region of Nepal, ~50% of trekkers who walk to
altitudes >4000 m over ≥5 days develop AMS, as do 84% of people who
fly directly to 3860 m. The incidences of HACE and HAPE are much
lower than that of AMS, with estimates in the range of 0.1–4%. Finally,
reentry HAPE, which in the past was generally limited to highlanders
(long-term residents of altitudes >2500 m) in the Americas, is now
being seen in Himalayan and Tibetan highlanders—and often misdiagnosed as a viral illness—as a result of recent rapid air, train, and
motorable-road access to high-altitude settlements.
■ PHYSIOLOGY
Ascent to a high altitude subjects the body to a decrease in barometric
pressure that results in a decreased partial pressure of oxygen in the
inspired gas in the lungs. This change leads in turn to less pressure,
driving oxygen diffusion from the alveoli and throughout the oxygen
cascade. A normal initial “struggle response” to such an ascent includes
increased ventilation—the cornerstone of acclimatization—mediated
by the carotid bodies. Hyperventilation may cause respiratory alkalosis
and dehydration. Respiratory alkalosis may be extreme, with an arterial
blood pH of >7.7 (e.g., at the summit of Everest). Alkalosis may depress
the ventilatory drive during sleep, with consequent periodic breathing
and hypoxemia. During early acclimatization, renal suppression of carbonic anhydrase and excretion of dilute alkaline urine combat alkalosis
and tend to bring the pH of the blood to normal. Other physiologic
changes during normal acclimatization include increased sympathetic
tone; increased erythropoietin levels, leading to increased hemoglobin
levels and red blood cell mass; increased tissue capillary density and
mitochondrial numbers; and higher levels of 2,3-bisphosphoglycerate,
enhancing oxygen utilization. Even with normal acclimatization, however, ascent to a high altitude decreases maximal exercise capacity (by
~1% for every 100 m gained above 1500 m) and increases susceptibility
to cold injury due to peripheral vasoconstriction. If the ascent is made
faster than the body can adapt to the stress of hypobaric hypoxemia,
altitude-related disease states can result.
■ GENETICS
Hypoxia-inducible factor, which acts as a master switch in highaltitude adaptation, controls transcriptional responses to hypoxia
throughout the body and is involved in the release of vascular
endothelial growth factor (VEGF) in the brain, erythropoiesis, and
other pulmonary and cardiac functions at high altitudes. In particular,
the gene EPAS1, which codes for transcriptional regulator hypoxiainducible factor 2α, appears to play an important role in the adaptation
of Tibetans living at high altitude, resulting in lower hemoglobin concentrations than are found in Han Chinese or South American highlanders. Other genes implicated include EGLN1 and PPARA, which are
also associated with hemoglobin concentration. Some evidence indicates that these genetic changes occurred within the past 3000 years,
which is very fast in evolutionary terms. An intriguing question is
whether the Sherpas’ well-known mountain-climbing ability is partially attributable to their Tibetan ancestry, with overrepresentation of
variants of EPAS. A striking recent finding is that some of these genetic
characteristics may stem from those of Denisovan hominids who were
contemporaries of the Neanderthals.
For acute altitude illness, a single gene variant is unlikely to be
found, but differences in the susceptibility of individuals and populations, familial clustering of cases, and a positive association of some
genetic variants all clearly support a role for genetics.
■ ACUTE MOUNTAIN SICKNESS AND HIGHALTITUDE CEREBRAL EDEMA
AMS is a neurologic syndrome characterized by nonspecific symptoms
(headache, nausea, fatigue, and dizziness), with a paucity of physical
findings, developing 6–12 h after ascent to a high altitude. AMS is a
clinical diagnosis. For uniformity in research studies, the Lake Louise
Scoring System, created at the 1991 International Hypoxia Symposium,
is generally used without the sleep disturbance score. AMS must be
distinguished from exhaustion, dehydration, hypothermia, alcoholic
hangover, and hyponatremia. AMS and HACE are thought to represent
opposite ends of a continuum of altitude-related neurologic disorders.
HACE (but not AMS) is an encephalopathy whose hallmarks are
ataxia and altered consciousness with diffuse cerebral involvement
but generally without focal neurologic deficits. Progression to these
signal manifestations can be rapid. Papilledema and, more commonly,
retinal hemorrhages may develop. In fact, retinal hemorrhages occur
frequently at ≥5000 m, even in individuals without clinical symptoms
of AMS or HACE.
Risk Factors The most important risk factors for the development
of altitude illness are the rate of ascent and a prior history of highaltitude illness. Exertion is a risk factor, but lack of physical fitness is
not. An attractive but still speculative hypothesis proposes that AMS
develops in people who have inadequate cerebrospinal capacity to
buffer the brain swelling that occurs at high altitude. Children and
adults seem to be equally affected, but people >50 years of age may be
less likely to develop AMS than younger people. In general, there is no
gender difference in AMS incidence. Sleep desaturation—a common
phenomenon at high altitude—is associated with AMS. Debilitating
fatigue consistent with severe AMS on descent from a summit is an
important risk factor for death in mountaineers. A prospective study
involving trekkers and climbers who ascended to altitudes between
4000 and 8848 m showed that high oxygen desaturation and low ventilatory response to hypoxia during exercise are independent predictors
of severe altitude illness. However, because there may be a large overlap
between groups of susceptible and nonsusceptible individuals, accurate cutoff values are hard to define. Prediction is made more difficult
because the pretest probabilities of HAPE and HACE are low. Neck
irradiation or surgery damaging the carotid bodies, respiratory tract
infections, and dehydration appear to be other potential risk factors
for altitude illness. Unless guided by clinical signs and symptoms, pulse
oximeter readings alone on a trek should not be used to predict AMS.
Pathophysiology Hypobaric hypoxia is the main trigger for altitude illness. In established AMS, raised intracranial pressure, increased
sympathetic activity, relative hypoventilation, fluid retention and
redistribution, and impaired gas exchange have all been well noted;
these factors may play an important role in the pathophysiology of
AMS. Severe hypoxemia can lead to a greater than normal increase in
cerebral blood flow. However, the exact mechanisms underlying AMS
and HACE are unknown. Evidence points to a central nervous system
process. MRI studies have suggested that vasogenic (interstitial) cerebral edema is a component of the pathophysiology of HACE. In the
Altitude Illness
Buddha Basnyat, Geoffrey Tabin
3618 PART 15 Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures
setting of high-altitude illness, the MRI findings shown in Fig. 462-1
are confirmatory of HACE, with increased signal in the white matter
and particularly in the splenium of the corpus callosum. In addition,
hemosiderin deposits in the corpus callosum have been characterized
as long-lasting footprints of HACE. Quantitative analysis in an MRI
study revealed that hypoxia is associated with mild vasogenic cerebral
edema irrespective of AMS. This finding is in keeping with case reports
of suddenly symptomatic brain tumors and of cranial nerve palsies
without AMS at high altitudes. Vasogenic edema may become cytotoxic (intracellular) in severe HACE.
Impaired cerebral autoregulation in the presence of hypoxic cerebral
vasodilation and altered permeability of the blood-brain barrier due
to hypoxia-induced chemical mediators like histamine, arachidonic
acid, and VEGF may all contribute to brain edema. In 1995, VEGF was
first proposed as a potent promoter of capillary leakage in the brain at
high altitude, and studies in mice have borne out this role. Although
studies of VEGF in climbers have yielded inconsistent results regarding its association with altitude illness, indirect evidence of a role for
this growth factor in AMS and HACE comes from the observation
that dexamethasone, when used in the prevention and treatment of
these conditions, blocks hypoxic upregulation of VEGF. Other factors
in the development of cerebral edema may be the release of calciummediated nitric oxide and neuronally mediated adenosine, which may
promote cerebral vasodilation. Venous outflow obstruction resulting
in increased brain capillary pressure is also thought to play an important role in the development of HACE. Lesions in the globus pallidum
(which is sensitive to hypoxia) leading to Parkinson’s disease have been
reported to be complications of HACE.
The pathophysiology of the most common and prominent symptom
of AMS—headache—remains unclear because the brain itself is an
insensate organ; only the meninges contain trigeminal sensory nerve
fibers. The cause of high-altitude headache is multifactorial. Various
chemicals and mechanical factors activate a final common pathway, the
trigeminovascular system. In the genesis of high-altitude headache, the
response to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and glucocorticoids
provides indirect evidence for involvement of the arachidonic acid
pathway and inflammation.
Prevention and Treatment (Table 462-1) Gradual ascent, with
adequate time for acclimatization, is the best method for the prevention
of altitude illness. Even though there may be individual variation in the
rate of acclimatization, a conservative approach would be a graded
ascent of ≤300 m from the previous day’s sleeping altitude above 3000 m,
and taking every third day of gain in sleeping altitude as an extra day
for acclimatization is helpful. Spending one night at an intermediate
altitude before proceeding to a higher altitude may enhance acclimatization and attenuate the risk of AMS. Another protective factor in AMS
is high-altitude exposure during the preceding 2 months; for example,
the incidence and severity of AMS at 4300 m are reduced by 50% with
an ascent after 1 week at an altitude ≥2000 m rather than with an ascent
from sea level. However, regarding the benefits of acclimatization,
clear-cut randomized studies are lacking. Repeated exposure at low
altitudes to hypobaric or normobaric hypoxia is termed preacclimatization. Preacclimatization is gaining popularity. For example, many
Everest climbers in the spring of 2019 claimed to use commercially
available “tents” at home with a hypoxic environment for weeks to
months in preparation for the climb. However, the optimal method
based on robust studies for preacclimatization is yet to be determined.
Clearly, a flexible itinerary that permits additional rest days will
be helpful. Sojourners to high-altitude locations must be aware of the
symptoms of altitude illness and should be encouraged not to ascend
further if these symptoms develop. Any hint of HAPE (see below) or
HACE mandates descent. Proper hydration (but not overhydration) in
high-altitude trekking and climbing, aimed at countering fluid loss due
to hyperventilation and sweating, may play a role in avoiding AMS.
Pharmacologic prophylaxis at the time of travel to high altitudes is
warranted for people with a history of AMS or when a graded ascent
and acclimatization are not possible—e.g., when rapid ascent is necessary for rescue purposes or when flight to a high-altitude location is
required. Acetazolamide is the drug of choice for AMS prevention. It
inhibits renal carbonic anhydrase, causing prompt bicarbonate diuresis
that leads to metabolic acidosis and hyperventilation. Acetazolamide
(125 mg twice daily), administered for 1 day before ascent and continued for about 3 days at the same altitude, is effective. Treatment
can be restarted if symptoms return after discontinuation of the drug.
FIGURE 462-1 T2 magnetic resonance image of the brain of a patient with highaltitude cerebral edema (HACE) shows marked swelling and a hyperintense
posterior body and splenium of the corpus callosum (area with dense opacity). The
patient, a climber, went on to climb Mount Everest about 9 months after this episode
of HACE. (Source: FJ Trayers 3rd: Wilderness preventive medicine. Wilderness
Environ Med 15:53, 2004.)
TABLE 462-1 Management of Altitude Illness
CONDITION MANAGEMENT
Acute mountain sickness
(AMS), milda
Discontinuation of ascent
Treatment with acetazolamide (250 mg q12h)
Descentb
AMS, moderatea Immediate descent for worsening symptoms
Use of low-flow oxygen if available
Treatment with acetazolamide (250 mg q12h) and/or
dexamethasone (4 mg q6h)c
Hyperbaric therapyd
High-altitude cerebral
edema (HACE)
Immediate descent or evacuation
Administration of oxygen (2–4 L/min)
Treatment with dexamethasone (8 mg PO/IM/IV; then
4 mg q6h)
Hyperbaric therapy if descent is not possible
High-altitude pulmonary
edema (HAPE)
Immediate descent or evacuation
Minimization of exertion while patient is kept warm
Administration of oxygen (4–6 L/min) to bring O2
saturation to >90%
Adjunctive therapy with nifedipinee
(30 mg, extendedrelease, q12h)
Hyperbaric therapy if descent is not possible
a
Categorization of cases as mild or moderate is a subjective judgment based on
the severity of headache and the presence and severity of other manifestations
(nausea, fatigue, dizziness). b
No fixed altitude is specified; the patient should
descend to a point below that at which symptoms developed. c
Acetazolamide treats
and dexamethasone masks symptoms. For prevention (as opposed to treatment) of
AMS, 125 mg of acetazolamide q12h or (when acetazolamide is contraindicated—
e.g., in people with a history of sulfa anaphylaxis) 4 mg of dexamethasone q12h
may be used. d
In hyperbaric therapy (Fig. 462-2), the patient is placed in a portable
altitude chamber or bag to simulate descent. e
Nifedipine at this dose is also
effective for the prevention of HAPE, as are tadalafil (10 mg twice daily), sildenafil
(50 mg three times per day), and dexamethasone (8 mg twice daily). Preventative
therapy should be continued for about 3 days after arriving at the target altitude.
If prompt descent follows arrival at target altitude, continuation of preventative
therapy is unnecessary.
3619Altitude Illness CHAPTER 462
Higher doses are not required. A meta-analysis limited to randomized
controlled trials revealed that 125 mg of acetazolamide twice daily was
effective in the prevention of AMS, with a relative-risk reduction of
~48% from values obtained with placebo. Even lower doses (62.5 mg
twice daily) have been reported to be effective. Paresthesia and a
tingling sensation are common side effects of acetazolamide. Some
other uncommon side effects are myopia and drowsiness. This drug
is a nonantibiotic sulfonamide that has low-level cross-reactivity with
sulfa antibiotics; as a result, severe reactions are rare. Dexamethasone
(8 mg/d in divided doses) is also effective. A large-scale, randomized,
double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in partially acclimatized trekkers
clearly showed that Ginkgo biloba is ineffective in the prevention of
AMS. In randomized studies, ibuprofen (600 mg three times daily) has
been shown to be beneficial in the prevention of AMS. Recently, acetaminophen (1 g three times daily) was as effective as ibuprofen at the
above dosage in a randomized, double-blind study, which did not have
a placebo arm. However, more definitive studies and (for ibuprofen) a
proper gastrointestinal bleeding risk assessment need to be conducted
before these drugs can be routinely recommended for AMS prevention.
Many drugs, including spironolactone, medroxyprogesterone, magnesium, calcium channel blockers, and antacids, confer no benefit in the
prevention of AMS. Starkly conflicting results from a number of trials
of inhaled budesonide for the prevention of AMS have recently been
published, but, in all likelihood, the drug is ineffective. Similarly, no
efficacy studies are available for coca leaves (a weak form of cocaine),
which are offered to high-altitude travelers in the Andes, or for soroche
pills, which contain aspirin, caffeine, and acetaminophen and are sold
over the counter in Bolivia and Peru. Finally, a word of caution applies
in the pharmacologic prevention of altitude illness. A fast-growing
population of climbers in pursuit of a summit are injudiciously using
prophylactic drugs such as glucocorticoids in an attempt to improve
their performance; the outcome can be tragic because of potentially
severe side effects of these drugs, especially if taken for a long duration.
For the treatment of mild AMS, rest alone with analgesic use may
be adequate. Descent and the use of acetazolamide and (if available)
oxygen are sufficient to treat most cases of moderate AMS. Even a minor
descent (400–500 m) may be adequate for symptom relief. For moderate
AMS or early HACE, dexamethasone (4 mg orally or parenterally) is
highly effective. For HACE, immediate descent is mandatory. When
descent is not possible because of poor weather conditions or darkness,
a simulation of descent in a portable hyperbaric chamber (Fig. 462-2)
can be very effective. Pressurization in the bag for 1–2 h often leads
to spectacular improvement and, like dexamethasone administration,
“buys time.” Thus, in certain high-altitude locations (e.g., remote
pilgrimage sites), the decision to bring along the lightweight hyperbaric
chamber may prove lifesaving. Like nifedipine, phosphodiesterase-5
inhibitors have no role in the treatment of AMS or HACE. Finally,
short-term oxygen inhalation using small cannisters of oxygen or by
visiting oxygen bars is unhelpful in the prevention of AMS.
■ HIGH-ALTITUDE PULMONARY EDEMA
Risk Factors and Manifestations Unlike HACE (a neurologic
disorder), HAPE is primarily a pulmonary problem and therefore is not
necessarily preceded by AMS. HAPE develops within 2–4 days after
arrival at high altitude; it rarely occurs after >4 or 5 days at the same
altitude, probably because of remodeling and adaptation that render
the pulmonary vasculature less susceptible to the effects of hypoxia.
A rapid rate of ascent, a history of HAPE, respiratory tract infections,
and cold environmental temperatures are risk factors. Men are more
susceptible than women. People with abnormalities of the cardiopulmonary circulation leading to pulmonary hypertension—e.g., mitral
stenosis, primary pulmonary hypertension, and unilateral absence
of the pulmonary artery—may be at increased risk of HAPE, even at
moderate altitudes. Although patent foramen ovale, a common condition, is four times more common among HAPE-susceptible individuals
than in the general population, there is no compelling evidence to
suggest causal effect. Echocardiography is recommended when HAPE
develops at relatively low altitudes (<3000 m) and whenever cardiopulmonary abnormalities predisposing to HAPE are suspected. The
differential diagnosis of HAPE includes anxiety attack, pneumonia,
pneumothorax, and pulmonary embolism.
The initial manifestation of HAPE may be a reduction in exercise
tolerance greater than that expected at the given altitude. Although a
dry, persistent cough may presage HAPE and may be followed by the
production of blood-tinged sputum, cough in the mountains is almost
universal and the mechanism is poorly understood. Tachypnea and
tachycardia, even at rest, are important markers as illness progresses.
Crackles may be heard on auscultation but are not diagnostic. HAPE
may be accompanied by signs of HACE. Patchy or localized opacities
(Fig. 462-3) or streaky interstitial edema may be noted on chest radiography. In the past, HAPE was mistaken for pneumonia due to the
cold or for heart failure due to hypoxia and exertion. Kerley B lines
or a bat-wing appearance are not seen on radiography. Electrocardiography may reveal right ventricular strain or even hypertrophy.
Hypoxemia and respiratory alkalosis are consistently present unless the
patient is taking acetazolamide, in which case metabolic acidosis may
supervene. Assessment of arterial blood gases is not necessary in the
evaluation of HAPE; an oxygen saturation reading with a pulse oximeter is generally adequate. The existence of a subclinical form of HAPE
has been suggested by an increased alveolar-arterial oxygen gradient
in Everest climbers near the summit, but hard evidence correlating
this abnormality with the development of clinically relevant HAPE is
FIGURE 462-2 A hyperbaric bag. The cylindrical, portable (<7 kg) nylon bag has
a one-way valve to prevent carbon dioxide buildup. A patient with severe acute
mountain sickness (AMS), high-altitude cerebral edema (HACE), or high-altitude
pulmonary edema (HAPE) is zipped inside the bag, which is continuously inflated
with a foot pedal. The increased barometric pressure (2 psi) inside the bag simulates
descent; for example, at 4250 m, the equivalent “elevation” inside the bag is ~2100 m.
No supplemental oxygen is required.
FIGURE 462-3 Chest radiograph of a patient with high-altitude pulmonary
edema shows opacity in the right middle and lower zones simulating pneumonic
consolidation. The opacity cleared almost completely in 2 days with descent and
supplemental oxygen.
3620 PART 15 Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures
lacking. Comet-tail scoring—an ultrasound technique initially validated in cardiogenic pulmonary edema—has been used for evaluation
of extravascular lung water at high altitude and has proven to be useful
in detecting HAPE (clinical or subclinical) and even in ascertaining
whether the presence of extravascular lung water is a harbinger of
HAPE in patients with AMS.
Pathophysiology HAPE is a noncardiogenic pulmonary edema
with normal pulmonary artery wedge pressure. It is characterized by
patchy pulmonary hypoxic vasoconstriction that leads to overperfusion in some areas. This abnormality leads in turn to increased pulmonary capillary pressure (>18 mmHg) and capillary “stress” failure.
The exact mechanism for this hypoxic vasoconstriction is unknown.
Endothelial dysfunction due to hypoxia may play a role by impairing
the release of nitric oxide, an endothelium-derived vasodilator. At high
altitude, HAPE-prone persons have reduced levels of exhaled nitric
oxide. The effectiveness of phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitors in alleviating altitude-induced pulmonary hypertension, decreased exercise
tolerance, and hypoxemia supports the role of nitric oxide in the pathogenesis of HAPE. One study demonstrated that prophylactic use of
tadalafil, a phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitor, decreases the risk of HAPE
by 65%. In contrast, the endothelium also synthesizes endothelin-1, a
potent vasoconstrictor whose concentrations are higher than average
in HAPE-prone mountaineers.
Exercise and cold lead to increased pulmonary intravascular pressure
and may predispose to HAPE. In addition, hypoxia-triggered increases
in sympathetic drive may lead to pulmonary venoconstriction and
extravasation into the alveoli from the pulmonary capillaries. Consistent with this concept, phentolamine, which elicits α-adrenergic blockade, improves hemodynamics and oxygenation in HAPE more than do
other vasodilators. The study of tadalafil cited above also investigated
dexamethasone in the prevention of HAPE. Surprisingly, dexamethasone reduced the incidence of HAPE by 78%—a greater decrease than
with tadalafil. Besides possibly increasing the availability of endothelial
nitric oxide, dexamethasone may have altered the excessive sympathetic
activity associated with HAPE: the heart rate of participants in the dexamethasone arm of the study was significantly lowered. Finally, people
susceptible to HAPE also display enhanced sympathetic activity during
short-term hypoxic breathing at low altitudes.
Because many patients with HAPE have fever, peripheral leukocytosis, and an increased erythrocyte sedimentation rate, inflammation
has been considered an etiologic factor in HAPE. However, strong
evidence suggests that inflammation in HAPE is an epiphenomenon
rather than the primary cause. Nevertheless, inflammatory processes
(e.g., those elicited by viral respiratory tract infections) do predispose
persons to HAPE—even those who are constitutionally resistant to its
development.
Another proposed mechanism for HAPE is impaired transepithelial
clearance of sodium and water from the alveoli. β-Adrenergic agonists
upregulate the clearance of alveolar fluid in animal models. In a single
double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled study of HAPE-susceptible
mountaineers, prophylactic inhalation of the β-adrenergic agonist salmeterol reduced the incidence of HAPE by 50%. However, the dosage
of salmeterol (125 μg twice daily) used was very high, which could
result in excessive tachycardia and tremors. Other effects of β agonists
may also contribute to the prevention of HAPE, and these findings are
in keeping with the concept that alveolar fluid clearance may play a
pathogenic role in this illness.
Prevention and Treatment (Table 462-1) Allowing sufficient
time for acclimatization by ascending gradually (as discussed above for
AMS and HACE) is the best way to prevent HAPE. Sustained-release
nifedipine (30 mg), given twice daily, prevents HAPE in people who
must ascend rapidly or who have a history of HAPE. Other drugs
for the prevention of HAPE are listed in Table 462-1 (footnote e).
Although dexamethasone is listed for prevention, its adverse effect
profile requires close monitoring. Acetazolamide has been shown to
blunt hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction in animal models, and this
observation warrants further study in HAPE prevention. However, one
large study failed to show a decrease in pulmonary vasoconstriction
in partially acclimatized individuals given acetazolamide. Inhaled
salmeterol is not recommended as clinical experience with this drug
is limited at high altitude. Finally, potent diuretics like furosemide
should be avoided in the treatment of HAPE. Early recognition is paramount in the treatment of HAPE, especially when it is not preceded
by the AMS symptoms of headache and nausea. Fatigue and dyspnea
at rest may be the only initial manifestations. Descent and the use of
supplementary oxygen (aimed at bringing oxygen saturation to >90%)
are the most effective therapeutic interventions. Exertion should be
kept to a minimum, and the patient should be kept warm. Hyperbaric
therapy (Fig. 462-2) in a portable altitude chamber may be lifesaving, especially if descent is not possible and oxygen is not available.
Oral sustained-release nifedipine (30 mg twice daily) can be used as
adjunctive therapy. No studies have investigated phosphodiesterase-5
inhibitors in the treatment of HAPE, but reports have described their
use in clinical practice. The mainstays of treatment remain descent and
(if available) oxygen.
In AMS, if symptoms abate (with or without acetazolamide), the
patient may reascend gradually to a higher altitude. Unlike that in acute
respiratory distress syndrome (another noncardiogenic pulmonary
edema), the architecture of the lung in HAPE is usually well preserved,
with rapid reversibility of abnormalities (Fig. 462-3). This fact has
allowed some people with HAPE to reascend slowly after a few days
of descent and rest. In HACE, reascent after a few days may not be
advisable during the same trip.
■ OTHER HIGH-ALTITUDE PROBLEMS
Sleep Impairment The mechanisms underlying sleep problems,
which are among the most common adverse reactions to high altitude,
include increased periodic breathing; changes in sleep architecture,
with increased time in lighter sleep stages; and changes in rapid eye
movement sleep. Sojourners should be reassured that sleep quality
improves with acclimatization. In cases where drugs do need to be
used, acetazolamide (125 mg before bedtime) is especially useful
because this agent decreases hypoxemic episodes and alleviates sleeping
disruptions caused by excessive periodic breathing. Whether combining acetazolamide with temazepam or zolpidem is more effective than
administering acetazolamide alone is unknown. In combinations, the
doses of temazepam and zolpidem should not be increased by >10 mg
at high altitudes. Limited evidence suggests that diazepam causes
hypoventilation at high altitudes and therefore is contraindicated. For
trekkers with obstructive sleep apnea who are using a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machine, the addition of acetazolamide,
which will decrease centrally mediated sleep apnea, may be helpful.
There is evidence to show that obstructive sleep apnea at high altitude
may decrease and “convert” to central sleep apnea.
Gastrointestinal Issues High-altitude exposure may be associated with increased gastric and duodenal bleeding, but further studies
are required to determine whether there is a causal effect. Because of
decreased atmospheric pressure and consequent intestinal gas expansion at high altitudes, many sojourners experience abdominal bloating
and distension as well as excessive flatus expulsion. In the absence of
diarrhea, these phenomena are normal, if sometimes uncomfortable.
Accompanying diarrhea, however, may indicate the involvement of
bacteria or Giardia parasites, which are common at many high-altitude
locations in the developing world. Prompt treatment with fluids and
empirical antibiotics may be required to combat dehydration in the
mountains. Hemorrhoids are common on high-altitude treks; treatment includes hot soaks, application of hydrocortisone ointment, and
measures to avoid constipation.
High-Altitude Cough High-altitude cough can be debilitating
and is sometimes severe enough to cause rib fracture, especially at
>5000 m. The etiology of this common problem is probably multifactorial. Although high-altitude cough has been attributed to inspiration
of cold dry air, this explanation appears not to be sufficient by itself;
in long-duration studies in hypobaric chambers, cough has occurred
3621Altitude Illness CHAPTER 462
despite controlled temperature and humidity. The implication is that
hypoxia also plays a role. Exercise can precipitate cough at high altitudes, possibly because of water loss from the respiratory tract. In general, infection does not seem to be a common etiology. Many trekkers
find it useful to wear a balaclava to trap some moisture and heat. In
most situations, cough resolves upon descent.
High-Altitude Neurologic Events Unrelated to “Altitude
Illness” Transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) and strokes have been
well described in high-altitude sojourners outside the setting of altitude
sickness. However, these descriptions are not based on cause (hypoxia)
and effect. In general, symptoms of AMS present gradually, whereas
many of these neurologic events happen suddenly. The population that
suffers strokes and TIAs at sea level is generally an older age group with
other risk factors, whereas those so afflicted at high altitudes are generally younger and probably have fewer risk factors for atherosclerotic
vascular disease. Other mechanisms (e.g., migraine, vasospasm, focal
edema, hypocapneic vasoconstriction, hypoxia in the watershed zones
of minimal cerebral blood flow, or cardiac right-to-left shunt) may be
operative in TIAs and strokes at high altitude.
Subarachnoid hemorrhage, transient global amnesia, delirium,
and cranial nerve palsies (e.g., lateral rectus palsy) occurring at high
altitudes but outside the setting of altitude sickness have been well
described. Syncope is common at moderately high altitudes, generally occurs shortly after ascent, usually resolves without descent, and
appears to be a vasovagal event related to hypoxemia. Seizures occur
rarely with HACE, but hypoxemia and hypocapnia, which are prevalent
at high altitudes, are well-known triggers that may contribute to new
or breakthrough seizures in predisposed individuals. Nevertheless,
the consensus among experts is that sojourners with well-controlled
seizure disorders can ascend to high altitudes.
Finally, persons with hypercoagulable conditions (e.g., antiphospholipid syndrome, protein C deficiency) who are asymptomatic at
sea level may experience cerebral venous thrombosis (possibly due to
enhanced blood viscosity triggered by polycythemia and dehydration)
at high altitudes. Proper history taking, examination, and prompt
investigations where possible will help define these conditions as entities separate from altitude sickness. Administration of oxygen (where
available) and prompt descent are the cornerstones of treatment of
most of these neurologic conditions.
Ocular Problems Ocular issues are common in sojourners to high
altitudes. Hypoxemia induced by altitude leads to increased retinal
blood flow, which can be visible as engorged retinal veins on ophthalmoscopic examination. Both high flow and hypoxemic vascular damage causing permeability have been implicated in a breakdown of the
blood-retina barrier and the formation of retinal hemorrhages. Blot,
dot, flame, and white-centered hemorrhages can be observed. These
hemorrhages usually resolve spontaneously with descent, with only
mild symptoms and no lasting visual damage in most healthy eyes. The
exception is hemorrhage in the macular area. Macular hemorrhages
can cause devastating initial visual loss, particularly if bilateral, and
have been reported to cause permanently decreased vision in a few
cases.
Stroke syndromes such as retinal vein occlusion, retinal artery
occlusion, ischemic optic neuropathy, and cortical visual loss have
all been reported. With unilateral vision loss, it is always important
to check for a relative afferent pupillary defect. Increased hematocrit
combined with dehydration may contribute to these maladies. Glaucomatous optic nerve damage may progress with hypoxemia of altitude.
Acetazolamide is helpful both in combating the respiratory alkalosis
that comes with increased ventilation at high altitude and in lowering
the interocular pressure; its use should be considered in patients with
stable controlled glaucoma. Macular degeneration and diabetic eye
disease are not directly exacerbated by ascent to high altitude. Dry
eye and solar damage to the cornea, known as “snow blindness,” are
common. Wearing of high-quality UV-blocking sunglasses, even on
cloudy days, and attention to protecting and supplementing the tear
film with artificial tear drops can greatly improve comfort and vision.
Although modern refractive surgeries, such as photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) and laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK), are stable at high
altitude, patients who have undergone radial keratotomy should be
cautioned that hypoxemia to the cornea can lead to swelling that shifts
the refraction during ascent.
Psychological/Psychiatric Problems Delirium characterized
by a sudden change in mental status, a short attention span, disorganized thinking, and an agitated state during the period of confusion
has been well described in mountain climbers and trekkers without a
prior history. In addition, anxiety attacks, often triggered at night by
excessive periodic breathing, are well documented. The contribution
of hypoxia to these conditions is unknown. Expedition medical kits
need to include antipsychotic injectable drugs to control psychosis in
patients in remote high-altitude locations.
■ PREEXISTING MEDICAL ISSUES
Because travel to high altitudes is increasingly popular, common conditions such as hypertension, coronary artery disease, and diabetes are
more frequently encountered among high-altitude sojourners. This
situation is of particular concern for the millions of elderly pilgrims
with medical problems who visit high-altitude sacred areas (e.g., in the
Himalayas) each year. In recent years, high-altitude travel has attracted
intrepid trekkers who are taking immunosuppressive medications
(e.g., kidney transplant recipients or patients undergoing chemotherapy). Recommended vaccinations and other precautions (e.g., hand
washing) may be especially important for this group. Although most
of these medical conditions do not appear to influence susceptibility to
altitude illness, they may be exacerbated by ascent to altitude, exertion
in cold conditions, and hypoxemia. Advice regarding the advisability of
high-altitude travel and the impact of high-altitude hypoxia on these
preexisting conditions is becoming increasingly relevant, but there are
no evidence-based guidelines. In addition, recommendations made
for relatively low altitudes (~3000 m) may not hold true for higher
altitudes (>4000 m), where hypoxic stress is greater. Personal risks and
benefits must be clearly thought through before ascent.
Hypertension At high altitudes, enhanced sympathetic activity
may lead to a transient rise in blood pressure. Occasionally, nonhypertensive, healthy, asymptomatic trekkers have pathologically high blood
pressure at high altitude that rapidly normalizes without medicines
on descent. Sojourners should continue to take their antihypertensive
medications at high altitudes. Importantly, hypertensive patients are
not more likely than others to develop altitude illness. Because the
probable mechanism of high-altitude hypertension is α-adrenergic
activity, anti-α-adrenergic drugs such as prazosin have been suggested
for symptomatic patients and those with labile hypertension. It is best
to start taking the drug several weeks before the trip and to carry a
sphygmomanometer if a trekker has labile hypertension. Sustainedrelease nifedipine may also be useful. A recent observational cohort
study of 672 hypertensive and nonhypertensive trekkers in the
Himalayas showed that most travelers, including those with wellcontrolled hypertension, can be reassured that their blood pressure will
remain relatively stable at high altitude. Although blood pressure may
be extremely elevated at high altitude in normotensive and hypertensive people, it is unlikely to cause symptoms.
Coronary Artery Disease Myocardial oxygen demand and maximal heart rate are reduced at high altitudes because the VO2
max
(maximal oxygen consumption) decreases with increasing altitude.
This effect may explain why signs of cardiac ischemia or dysfunction
usually are not seen in healthy persons at high altitudes. Asymptomatic, fit individuals with no risk factors need not undergo any tests for
coronary artery disease before ascent. For persons with ischemic heart
disease, previous myocardial infarction, angioplasty, and/or bypass
surgery, an exercise treadmill test is indicated. A strongly positive
treadmill test is a contraindication for high-altitude trips. Patients with
poorly controlled arrhythmias should avoid high-altitude travel, but
patients with arrhythmias that are well controlled with antiarrhythmic
medications do not seem to be at increased risk. Sudden cardiac deaths
3622 PART 15 Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures
are not noted with a greater frequency in the Alps than at lower altitudes; although sudden cardiac deaths are encountered every trekking
season in the higher Himalayan range, accurate documentation is
lacking.
Cerebrovascular Disease Patients with TIAs should avoid travel
to high altitude for at least 3 months. Patients with known cerebral
aneurysm should also avoid high-altitude travel because of possible
rupture of the aneurysm due to increased cerebral blood flow at high
altitude.
Migraine Trekkers with a history of migraine may have an increased
likelihood of suffering from AMS and may also be predisposed to
headaches including altered character of their migraine presenting
with focal neurologic deficits. Oxygen inhalation may reduce AMStriggered headache, whereas a migraine headache usually persists even
after 10–15 min of oxygen inhalation.
Asthma Although cold air and exercise may provoke acute bronchoconstriction, asthmatic patients usually have fewer problems at
high than at low altitudes, possibly because of decreased allergen levels
and increased circulating catecholamine levels. Nevertheless, asthmatic
individuals should carry all their medications, including oral glucocorticoids, with proper instructions for use in case of an exacerbation.
Severely asthmatic persons should be cautioned against ascending to
high altitudes.
Pregnancy In general, low-risk pregnant women ascending to
3000 m are not at special risk except for the relative unavailability of
medical care in many high-altitude locations, especially in developing
countries. Despite the lack of firm data on this point, venturing higher
than 3000 m to altitudes at which oxygen saturation drops steeply
seems unadvisable for pregnant women.
Obesity Although living at a high altitude has been suggested as a
means of controlling obesity, obesity has also been reported to be a risk
factor for AMS, probably because nocturnal hypoxemia is more pronounced in obese individuals. Hypoxemia may also lead to greater pulmonary hypertension, thus possibly predisposing the trekker to HAPE.
Sickle Cell Disease High altitude is one of the rare environmental
exposures that occasionally provokes a crisis in persons with sickle
cell anemia. Even when traversing mountain passes as low as 2500 m,
people with sickle cell anemia have been known to have a vaso-occlusive
crisis. Patients with known sickle cell anemia who need to travel to
high altitudes should use supplemental oxygen and travel with caution.
Thalassemia has not been known to cause problems at high altitude.
Diabetes Mellitus Well-controlled diabetes is not a contraindication for travel to high altitude. Most of the high-altitude diabetes
advice is based on patients with type 1 diabetes and not type 2 diabetic
patients with comorbidities. An eye examination before travel may be
useful. Insulin pumps are increasingly used, but bubble formation in
the system may need to be closely monitored. Diabetic patients need
to carry a reliable glucometer. Ready access to sweets is also essential.
It is important for companions of diabetic trekkers to be fully aware of
potential problems like hypoglycemia. Dexamethasone, as far as possible, should be avoided in the prevention or treatment of altitude illness
in a diabetic patient.
Chronic Lung Disease Depending on disease severity and access
to medical care, preexisting lung disease may not always preclude
high-altitude travel. A proper pretravel evaluation must be conducted.
Supplemental oxygen may be required if the predicted PaO2
for the altitude is <50–55 mmHg. Preexisting pulmonary hypertension may also
need to be assessed in these patients. If the result is positive, patients
should be discouraged from ascending to high altitudes; if such travel
is necessary, treatment with sustained-release nifedipine (20 mg twice a
day) should be considered. Small-scale studies have revealed that when
patients with bullous disease reach ~5000 m, bullous expansion and
pneumothorax are not noted. Compared with information on chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease, fewer data exist about the safety of
travel to high altitude for people with pulmonary fibrosis, but acute
exacerbation of pulmonary fibrosis has been seen at high altitude. A
handheld pulse oximeter can be useful to check for oxygen saturation.
Chronic Kidney Disease Patients with chronic kidney disease
can tolerate short-term stays at high altitudes, but theoretical concern
persists about progression to end-stage renal disease. Acetazolamide,
the drug most commonly used for altitude sickness, should be avoided
by anyone with preexisting metabolic acidosis, which can be exacerbated by this drug. In addition, the acetazolamide dosage should be
adjusted when the glomerular filtration rate falls to <50 mL/min, and
the drug should not be used at all if this value falls to <10 mL/min.
Cirrhosis Of patients with cirrhosis, 16% may have portopulmonary arterial hypertension, and 32% may have hepatopulmonary
syndrome; these conditions may be detrimental at high altitude as they
may cause exaggerated hypoxemia. Thus, screening for these problems
is important in cirrhotic patients planning a high-altitude trip. In addition, acetazolamide may be inadvisable in these patients as the drug
may increase the risk of hepatic encephalopathy.
Dental Problems Air resulting from decay in the root system
could expand on ascent and lead to increasing pain. A good dental
checkup before a trekking or climbing trip may be prudent.
■ CHRONIC MOUNTAIN SICKNESS AND HIGHALTITUDE PULMONARY HYPERTENSION IN
HIGHLANDERS
The largest populations of highlanders live in the South American
Andes, the Tibetan Plateau, and parts of Ethiopia. Chronic mountain
sickness (Monge’s disease) is a disease in highlanders that is characterized by excessive erythrocytosis with moderate to severe pulmonary
hypertension leading to cor pulmonale. This condition was originally described in South America and has also been documented in
Colorado and in the Han Chinese population in Tibet; it is much less
common in Tibetans or in Ethiopian highlanders. Migration to a low
altitude results in the resolution of chronic mountain illness. Venesection and acetazolamide are helpful.
High-altitude pulmonary hypertension is also a subacute disease
of long-term high-altitude residents. Unlike Monge’s disease, this
syndrome is characterized primarily by pulmonary hypertension
(not erythrocytosis) leading to heart failure. Indian soldiers living at
extreme altitudes for prolonged periods and Han Chinese infants born
in Tibet have presented with the adult and infantile forms, respectively.
High-altitude pulmonary hypertension bears a striking pathophysiologic resemblance to brisket disease in cattle. Descent to a lower
altitude is curative.
■ FURTHER READING
Basnyat B: High altitude pilgrimage medicine. High Alt Med Biol
15:434, 2014.
Basnyat B, Murdoch D: High altitude illness. Lancet 361:1967, 2003.
Hillebrandt D et al: UIAA medical commission recommendations
for mountaineers, hillwalkers, trekkers, and rock and ice climbers
with diabetes. High Alt Med Biol, 2018. [Epub ahead of print]
Keyes LE et al: Blood pressure and altitude: An observational cohort
study of hypertensive and nonhypertensive Himalayan trekkers in
Nepal. High Alt Med Biol 18:267, 2017.
Luks AM et al: Wilderness Medical Society practice guidelines for
the prevention and treatment of acute altitude illness: 2019 update.
Wilderness Environ Med 30:S3, 2019.
Mcintosh SE et al: Reduced acetazolamide dosing in countering altitude illness: A comparison of 62.5 vs 125 mg (the RADICAL Trial).
Wilderness Environ Med 30:12, 2019.
Roach RC et al: Mountain medicine, in Wilderness Medicine, 7th ed.
PS Auerbach et al (eds). Philadelphia, Elsevier, 2017, pp 2–39.
3623Hyperbaric and Diving Medicine CHAPTER 463
WHAT IS HYPERBARIC
AND DIVING MEDICINE?
Hyperbaric medicine is the treatment of health disorders using wholebody exposure to pressures >101.3 kPa (1 atmosphere or 760 mmHg).
In practice, this almost always means the administration of hyperbaric
oxygen therapy (HBO2
T). The Undersea and Hyperbaric Medical
Society (UHMS) defines HBO2
T as: “an intervention in which an
individual breathes near 100% oxygen intermittently while inside
a hyperbaric chamber that is pressurized to greater than sea level
pressure (1 atmosphere absolute, or ATA). For clinical purposes, the
pressure must equal or exceed 1.4 ATA.” The chamber is an airtight
vessel variously called a hyperbaric chamber, recompression chamber,
or decompression chamber, depending on the clinical and historical
context. Such chambers may be capable of compressing a single patient
(a monoplace chamber) or multiple patients and attendants as required
(a multiplace chamber) (Figs. 463-1 and 463-2). Historically, these
compression chambers were first used for the treatment of divers and
compressed air workers suffering decompression sickness (DCS; “the
bends”). Although the prevention and treatment of disorders arising
after decompression in diving, aviation, and space flight have developed into a specialized field of their own, they remain closely linked to
the broader practice of hyperbaric medicine.
Despite an increased understanding of mechanisms and an improving evidence basis, hyperbaric medicine has struggled to achieve
widespread recognition as a “legitimate” therapeutic measure. There
are several contributing factors, but high among them are a poor
grounding in general oxygen physiology and oxygen therapy at medical
schools and a continuing tradition of charlatans advocating hyperbaric
therapy (often using air) as a panacea. Funding for both basic and clinical research has been difficult in an environment where the pharmacologic agent under study is abundant, cheap, and unpatentable. There
are signs of an improved appreciation of the potential importance of
HBO2
T with significant National Institutes of Health (NIH) funding
for mechanisms research, from the U.S. military for clinical investigation, and as evidenced by the recent appreciation of HBO2
T as a
potentially useful tool for improving oxygenation in severe COVID-19
(see “Further Readings”).
MECHANISMS OF HYPERBARIC OXYGEN
Increased hydrostatic pressure will reduce the volume of any bubbles present within the body (see “Diving Medicine”), and this is
partly responsible for the success of prompt recompression in DCS
and arterial gas embolism. Supplemental oxygen breathing has a
463
dose-dependent effect on oxygen transport, ranging from improvement in hemoglobin oxygen saturation when a few liters per minute
are delivered by simple mask at 101.3 kPa (1 ATA) to raising the dissolved plasma oxygen sufficiently to sustain life without the need for
hemoglobin at all when 100% oxygen is breathed at 303.9 kPa (3 ATA).
Most HBO2
T regimens involve oxygen breathing at between 202.6 and
283.6 kPa (2 and 2.8 ATA), and the resultant increase in arterial oxygen
tensions to >133.3 kPa (1000 mmHg) has widespread physiologic and
pharmacologic consequences (Fig. 463-3).
One direct consequence of such high intravascular tension is to
increase greatly the effective capillary-tissue diffusion distance for
oxygen such that oxygen-dependent cellular processes can resume in
hypoxic tissues. Important as this may be, the mechanism of action is
not limited to this restoration of oxygenation in hypoxic tissue. Indeed,
there are pharmacologic effects that are profound and long-lasting.
Although removal from the hyperbaric chamber results in a rapid
return of poorly vascularized tissues to their hypoxic state, even a
single dose of HBO2
T produces changes in fibroblast, leukocyte and
angiogenic functions, and antioxidant defenses that persist many hours
after oxygen tensions are returned to pretreatment levels.
It is widely accepted that oxygen in high doses produces adverse
effects due to the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as
superoxide (O2
–
) and hydrogen peroxide (H2
O2
). It has become increasingly clear over the past decade that both ROS and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) such as nitric oxide (NO) participate in diverse intracellular
signaling pathways involved in the production of a range of cytokines,
growth factors, and other inflammatory and repair modulators. Such
mechanisms are complex and at times apparently paradoxical. For
example, when used to treat chronic hypoxic wounds, HBO2
T has been
shown to enhance the clearance of cellular debris and bacteria by providing the substrate for macrophage phagocytosis; stimulate growth factor
synthesis by increased production and stabilization of hypoxia-inducible
factor 1 (HIF-1); inhibit leukocyte activation and adherence to damaged
endothelium; and mobilize CD34+ pluripotent vasculogenic progenitor
cells from the bone marrow. The interactions between these mechanisms
remain a very active field of investigation. One exciting development
is the concept of hyperoxic preconditioning in which a short exposure
to HBO2
can induce tissue protection against future hypoxic/ischemic
insult, most likely through an inhibition of mitochondrial permeability
transition pore (MPTP) opening and the release of cytochrome c. By
targeting these mechanisms of cell death during reperfusion events,
HBO2
has potential applications in a variety of settings including organ
transplantation. One randomized clinical trial suggested that HBO2
T
prior to coronary artery bypass grafting reduces biochemical markers of
ischemic stress and improves neurocognitive outcomes.
ADVERSE EFFECTS OF THERAPY
HBO2
T is generally well tolerated and safe in clinical practice. About
17% of patients experience an adverse event at some time during their
treatment course, and most are mild and self-limiting. Adverse effects
Hyperbaric and Diving
Medicine
Michael H. Bennett, Simon J. Mitchell
FIGURE 463-1 A monoplace chamber. (Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney.)
FIGURE 463-2 A chamber designed to treat multiple patients. (Karolinska University
Hospital.)
3624 PART 15 Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures
are associated with both alterations in pressure (barotrauma) and the
administration of oxygen.
■ BAROTRAUMA
Barotrauma occurs when any noncompliant gas-filled space within
the body does not equalize with environmental pressure during compression or decompression. About 10% of patients complain of some
difficulty equalizing middle-ear pressure early in compression, and
although most of these problems are minor and can be overcome with
training, 2–5% of conscious patients require middle-ear ventilation
tubes or formal grommets across the tympanic membrane. Unconscious patients cannot equalize and should have middle-ear ventilation
tubes placed prior to compression if possible. Other less common sites
for barotrauma of compression include the respiratory sinuses and
dental caries. The lungs are potentially vulnerable to barotrauma of
decompression as described below in the section on diving medicine,
but the decompression following HBO2
T is so slow that pulmonary gas
trapping is extremely rare in the absence of an undrained pneumothorax or lesions such as bullae.
■ OXYGEN TOXICITY
The practical limit to the dose of oxygen, either in a single treatment
session or in a series of daily sessions, is oxygen toxicity. The most
common acute manifestation is a seizure, often preceded by anxiety
and agitation, during which time a switch from oxygen to air breathing
may avoid the convulsion. Hyperoxic seizures are typically generalized
tonic-clonic seizures followed by a variable postictal period. The cause
is an overwhelming of the antioxidant defense systems within the
brain. Although clearly dose-dependent, onset is very variable both
between individuals and within the same individual on different days.
In routine clinical hyperbaric practice, the incidence is ~1:1500 to
1:3000 compressions.
Chronic oxygen poisoning most commonly manifests as myopic
shift. This is due to alterations in the refractive index of the lens
following oxidative damage that reduces the solubility of lenticular
proteins in a process similar to that associated with senescent cataract
formation. Up to 75% of patients show deterioration in visual acuity
after a course of 30 treatments at 202.6 kPa (2 ATA). Although most
return to pretreatment values 6–12 weeks after cessation of treatment, a
small proportion do not recover. A more rapid maturation of preexisting cataracts has occasionally been associated with HBO2
T. Although
a theoretical problem, the development of pulmonary oxygen toxicity
over time does not seem to be problematic in practice—probably due
to the intermittent nature of the exposure.
CONTRAINDICATIONS TO
HYPERBARIC OXYGEN
There are few absolute contraindications to HBO2
T. The most commonly encountered is an untreated pneumothorax. A pneumothorax
may expand rapidly on decompression and come under tension. Prior
to any compression, patients with a pneumothorax should have a patent chest drain in place. The presence of other obvious risk factors for
pulmonary gas trapping such as bullae should trigger a very cautious
analysis of the risks of treatment versus benefit. Prior bleomycin treatment deserves special mention because of its association with a partially
dose-dependent pneumonitis in ~20% of people. These individuals
appear to be at particular risk for rapid deterioration of ventilatory
function following exposure to high oxygen tensions. The relationship
between distant bleomycin exposure and subsequent risk of pulmonary oxygen toxicity is uncertain; however, late pulmonary fibrosis is a
potential complication of bleomycin, and any patient with a history of
receiving this drug should be carefully counseled prior to exposure to
HBO2
T. For those recently exposed to doses >300,000 IU (200 mg) and
whose course was complicated by a respiratory reaction to bleomycin,
compression should be avoided except in a life-threatening situation.
INDICATIONS FOR HYPERBARIC OXYGEN
The appropriate indications for HBO2
T are controversial and evolving. Practitioners in this area are in an unusual position. Unlike most
branches of medicine, hyperbaric physicians do not deal with a range
of disorders within a defined organ system, nor are they masters
of a therapy specifically designed for a single category of disorders.
Hyperbaric oxygen
Restoration of
tissue normoxia
Edema
reduction
Hyperoxic
vasoconstriction
↑Wound growth
factors
Stem cell
mobilization
↓β2 integrin
function
Enhanced phagocytosis,
angiogenesis, and
fibroblast activity
Ischemic
preconditioning,
e.g., HIF-1 HO-1
Wound healing,
radiation tissue injury
Threatened grafts/flaps
cadaveric organ preservation
Enhanced inert gas
diffusion gradients between
bubble, tissue, and lungs
High
arterial PO2
Hydrostatic
compression
Bubble
volume
reduction
DCS
CAGE
Enhanced O2 diffusion Osmotic effect Generation of ROS and RNS
Crush injury
FIGURE 463-3 Mechanisms of action of hyperbaric oxygen. There are many consequences of compression and oxygen breathing. The cell-signaling effects of hyperbaric
oxygen therapy (HBO2
T) are the least understood but potentially most important. Examples of indications for use are shown in the shaded boxes. CAGE, cerebral arterial
gas embolism; DCS, decompression sickness; HIF-1, hypoxia-inducible factor-1; HO-1, hemoxygenase 1; RNS, reactive nitrogen species; ROS, reactive oxygen species.
3625Hyperbaric and Diving Medicine CHAPTER 463
Inevitably, the encroachment of hyperbaric physicians into other
medical fields generates suspicion from specialist practitioners in
those fields. At the same time, this relatively benign therapy, the prescription and delivery of which requires no medical license in most
jurisdictions (including the United States), attracts both charlatans
and well-motivated proselytizers who tout the benefits of oxygen for
a plethora of chronic incurable diseases. This battle on two fronts has
meant that mainstream hyperbaric physicians have been particularly
careful to claim effectiveness only for those conditions where there is a
reasonable body of supporting evidence.
In 1977, the UHMS systematically examined claims for the use of
HBO2
T in >100 disorders and found sufficient evidence to support
routine use in only 12. The Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Committee
of that organization has continued to update this list periodically with
an increasingly formalized system of appraisal for new indications and
emerging evidence (Table 463-1). Around the world, other relevant
medical organizations have generally taken a similar approach. Indications vary considerably across the globe—particularly those recommended by hyperbaric medical societies in Russia and China where
HBO2
T has gained much wider support than in the United States,
Europe, and Australasia. Nevertheless, there are now 31 Cochrane
reviews summarizing the randomized trial evidence for 27 putative
indications, including attempts to examine the cost-effectiveness of
HBO2
T. Table 463-2 is a synthesis of these two approaches and lists
the estimated cost of attaining health outcomes with the use of HBO2
T.
Any savings associated with alternative treatment strategies avoided as
a result of HBO2
T are not accounted for in these estimates (e.g., the
avoidance of lower leg amputation in diabetic foot ulcers). Following
are short reviews of three important indications currently accepted by
the UHMS.
■ LATE RADIATION TISSUE INJURY
Radiotherapy is a well-established treatment for suitable malignancies. In the United States alone, ~300,000 individuals annually will
become long-term survivors of cancer treated by irradiation. Serious
radiation-related complications developing months or years after
treatment (late radiation tissue injury [LRTI]) will significantly affect
between 5 and 15% of those long-term survivors, although incidence
varies widely with dose, age, and site. LRTI is most common in the
head and neck, chest wall, breast, and pelvis.
Pathology and Clinical Course With time, tissues undergo a
progressive deterioration characterized by a reduction in the density
of small blood vessels (reduced vascularity) and the replacement
of normal tissue with dense fibrous tissue (fibrosis). An alternative
model of pathogenesis suggests that rather than a primary hypoxia, the
principal trigger is an overexpression of inflammatory cytokines that
promote fibrosis, probably through oxidative stress and mitochondrial
dysfunction, and a secondary tissue hypoxia. Ultimately, and often
triggered by a further physical insult such as surgery or infection, there
may be insufficient oxygen to sustain normal function, and the tissue
becomes necrotic (radiation necrosis). LRTI may be life-threatening
and significantly reduce quality of life. Historically, the management of
these injuries has been unsatisfactory. Conservative treatment is usually restricted to symptom management, whereas definitive treatment
traditionally entails surgery to remove the affected part and extensive
repair. Surgical intervention in an irradiated field is often disfiguring
and associated with an increased incidence of delayed healing, breakdown of a surgical wound, or infection. HBO2
T may act by several
mechanisms to improve this situation, including edema reduction,
vasculogenesis, and enhancement of macrophage activity (Fig. 463-3).
The intermittent application of HBO2
is the only intervention shown to
increase the microvascular density in irradiated tissue.
Clinical Evidence The typical course of HBO2
T consists of 30
once-daily compressions to 202.6–243.1 kPa (2–2.4 ATA) for 1.5–2 h
each session, often bracketed around surgical intervention if required.
Although HBO2
T has been used for LRTI since at least 1975, most
clinical studies have been limited to small case series or individual
case reports. In a review, Feldmeier and Hampson located 71 such
reports involving a total of 1193 patients across eight different tissues.
There were clinically significant improvements in the majority of
patients, and only 7 of 71 reports indicated a generally poor response
to HBO2
T. A Cochrane systematic review with meta-analysis included
14 randomized trials published since 1985 and drew the following
conclusions (see Table 463-2 for numbers needed to treat): HBO2
T
improves healing in radiation proctitis (relative risk [RR] of healing
with HBO2
T, 1.72; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.0–2.9) and achievement of mucosal cover of bone after hemimandibulectomy and reconstruction of the mandible (RR, 1. 3; 95% CI, 1.1–1.6); HBO2
T prevents
the development of osteoradionecrosis following tooth extraction from
a radiation field (RR, 1.4; 95% CI, 1.08–1.7) and reduces the risk of
wound dehiscence following grafts and flaps in the head and neck (RR,
4.2; 95% CI, 1.1–16.8). Conversely, there was no evidence of benefit in
established radiation brachial plexus lesions or brain injury.
■ SELECTED PROBLEM WOUNDS
A problem wound is any cutaneous ulceration that requires a prolonged time to heal, does not heal, or recurs. In general, wounds
referred to hyperbaric facilities are those where sustained attempts to
heal by other means have failed. Problem wounds are common and
constitute a significant health problem. It has been estimated that 1%
of the population of industrialized countries will experience a leg ulcer
at some time. The global cost of chronic wound care may be as high as
U.S. $25 billion per year.
Pathology and Clinical Course By definition, chronic wounds
are indolent or progressive and resistant to the wide array of treatments applied. Although there are many contributing factors, most
commonly, these wounds arise in association with one or more comorbidities such as diabetes, peripheral venous or arterial disease, or prolonged pressure (decubitus ulcers). First-line treatments are aimed at
correction of the underlying pathology (e.g., vascular reconstruction,
compression bandaging, or normalization of blood glucose level), and
HBO2
T is an adjunctive therapy to good general wound care practice
to maximize the chance of healing.
For most indolent wounds, hypoxia is a major contributor to failure
to heal. Many guidelines to patient selection for HBO2
T include the
interpretation of transcutaneous oxygen tensions around the wound
while breathing air and oxygen at pressure (Fig. 463-4). Wound healing is a complex and incompletely understood process. While it appears
that in acute wounds healing is stimulated by the initial hypoxia, low
pH, and high lactate concentrations found in freshly injured tissue,
some elements of tissue repair are extremely oxygen dependent, for
example, collagen elaboration and deposition by fibroblasts and bacterial killing by macrophages. In this complicated interaction between
TABLE 463-1 Current List of Indications for Hyperbaric Oxygen
Therapy
1. Air or gas embolism (includes diving-related, iatrogenic, and accidental
causes)
2. Carbon monoxide poisoning (including poisoning complicated by cyanide
poisoning)
3. Clostridial myositis and myonecrosis (gas gangrene)
4. Crush injury, compartment syndrome, and acute traumatic ischemias
5. Decompression sickness
6. Arterial insufficiency including central retinal arterial occlusion and problem
wounds
7. Severe anemia
8. Intracranial abscess
9. Necrotizing soft tissue infections (e.g., Fournier’s gangrene)
10. Osteomyelitis (refractory to other therapy)
11. Delayed radiation injury (soft-tissue injury and bony necrosis)
12. Skin grafts and flaps (compromised)
13. Acute thermal burn injury
14. Sudden sensorineural hearing loss
Source: The Undersea and Hyperbaric Medical Society (2021).
3626 PART 15 Disorders Associated with Environmental Exposures
TABLE 463-2 Selected Indications for Which There Is Promising Efficacy for the Application of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy
DIAGNOSIS
OUTCOME (NUMBER OF
SESSIONS) NNT AND 95% CI
ESTIMATED COST TO PRODUCE
ONE EXTRA FAVORABLE
OUTCOME AND 95% CI (USD) COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Radiation tissue injury More information is required on the subset of disease severity, the affected tissue type that is most likely to benefit, and the time over
which benefit may persist.
Resolved proctitis (30) 3 22,392 Large ongoing multicenter trial
2–11 14,928–82,104
Healed mandible (30) 4 29,184 Based on one poorly reported study
2–8 14,592–58,368
Mucosal cover in ORN (30) 3 29,888 Based on one poorly reported study
2–4 14,592–29,184
Bony continuity in ORN (30) 4 29,184 Based on one poorly reported study
2–8 14,592–58,368
Prevention of ORN after dental
extraction (30)
4 29,184 Based on a single study
2–13 14,592–94,848
Prevention of dehiscence (30) 5 36,480 Based on one poorly reported study
3–8 21,888–58,368
Chronic wounds More information is required on the subset of disease severity or classification most likely to benefit, the time over which benefit may
persist, and the most appropriate oxygen dose. Economic analysis is required.
Diabetic ulcer healed at
1 year (30)
2 14,928 Based on one small study, more research
required
1–5 7464–37,320
Diabetic ulcer, major
amputation avoided (30)
4 29,856 Three small studies; outcome over a
longer time period required
3–11 22,392–82,104
ISSNHL No evidence of benefit >2 weeks after onset. More research is required to define the role (if any) of HBO2
T in routine therapy.
Improvement of 25% in hearing
loss within 2 weeks of onset
(15)
5 18,240 Some improvement in hearing, but
functional significance unknown
3–20 10,944–72,960
Acute coronary syndrome More information is required on the subset of disease severity and timing of therapy most likely to result in benefit. Given the potential
of HBO2
T in modifying ischemia-reperfusion injury, attention should be given to the combination of HBO2
T and thrombolysis in early
management and in the prevention of restenosis after stent placement.
Episode of MACE (5) 4 4864 Based on a single small study; more
research required
3–10 3648–12,160
Incidence of significant
dysrhythmia (5)
6 7296 Based on a single moderately powered
study in the 1970s
3–24 3648–29,184
Traumatic brain injury Limited evidence that for acute injury HBO2
T reduces mortality but not functional morbidity. Routine use not yet justified.
Mortality (15) 7 34,104 Based on four heterogeneous studies
4–22 19,488–58,464
Enhancement of
radiotherapy
There is some evidence that HBO2
T improves local tumor control, reduces mortality for cancers of the head and neck, and reduces the
chance of local tumor recurrence in cancers of the head, neck, and uterine cervix.
Head and neck cancer: 5-year
mortality (12)
5 14,592 Based on trials performed in the 1970s and
1980s. There may be some confounding by
radiation fractionation schedule.
3–14 8755–40,858
Local recurrence 1 year (12) 5 14,592 May no longer be relevant to therapy
4–8 11,674–23,347
Cancer of uterine cervix: Local
recurrence at 2 years (20)
5 24,320 As above
4–8 19,456–38,912
Decompression illnessa Reasonable evidence for reduced number of HBO2
T sessions but similar outcomes when NSAID added.
Reduction of HBO2
T treatment
requirement by 1
5
3–18
N/R Single appropriately powered randomized
trial
a
Tenoxicam used as an adjunct to recompression on oxygen.
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; HBO2
T, hyperbaric oxygen therapy; ISSNHL, idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss; MACE, major adverse cardiac events; NNT,
number needed to treat; N/R, not remarkable; NSAID, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug; ORN, osteoradionecrosis; USD, U.S. dollars.
Source: M Bennett: The evidence-basis of diving and hyperbaric medicine—a synthesis of the high level evidence with meta-analysis. http://unsworks.unsw.edu.au/fapi/
datastream/unsworks:949/SOURCE01?view=true.
No comments:
Post a Comment
اكتب تعليق حول الموضوع